I find the complacency within the Princeton students David
Brooks describes when he says "They are disconcertingly comfortable with
authority. That's the most common complaint the faculty has of Princeton
students. They're eager to please, eager to jump through whatever hoops the
faculty puts in front of them, eager to conform." to be slightly
concerning. Maybe this has changed since the article was written 20 years ago,
but the image I have of students who are selected to attend these highly
regarded institutions, are the types of people who want to find a larger
purpose in life, who want to break the mold, are looking to make change, and
find new ways to improve and have an impact on the world. I also thought these “challenging
the norms” types of people are what the university looked for in its pupils.
I can also see agreeable, easy going, people pleasers to be
a good fit for certain degree paths that Brooks discusses like investing or
finance. With a position that is routine and doesn’t call for change, there
really is no need to fix something that’s not broken. Recently, I’ve seen a
spike in the availability of investment aps and digital currency ATM’s. I’m
curious if these types of new investing/currency platforms and devices were created
by individuals with a more “poetic” or “prudential” frame of mind? Also, can one change their frame of mind
throughout their lifetime?
I grew up in a very small town where a “poetic” frame of
mind was uncommon. In my younger years, I felt I had a more “prudential” frame
of mind, but as I continue to grow and work within a higher education role, I
have found myself inheriting a more “poetic” frame of mind. Even my family has
pointed out the differences in the way I approach and view life now. For
example, difficult conversations are an educational conversation and I respect differing
viewpoints that I used to tune out. I have accepted a growth mindset and I can’t
pinpoint where, or when that started, but I know it’s not how I used to feel. I
remember having the mindset during collage that this was my means to an end, as
Hagardon said. I’m glad I don’t think that way anymore. I now feel a sense of
freedom, at least in my mind, from the typical mundane everyday routine.
Conversations are more interesting, I enjoy learning about others, and hearing new points of view. I’m not sure how this mindset will affect my leadership style but I’m interested to see where it will take me.
My wife often reminds me that it is a skill to be comfortable with the uncomfortable. It is not easy to question or push back or even offer alternative view points, especially when you highly respect the leader and value their approval. I think there are many people (maybe all of us in one way or another) that are comfortable being told what to do and very uncomfortable trying to figure out how to do it on our own. We don't teach the skill of formulating good questions. We also need to better cultivate the skill of detaching emotion and meaning to other's questions so we can have more honest and open conversations. Even as we've talked about empathy in class I find that unless the conversation is "comfortable" a lot of people would rather throw empathy out the window--default to name calling, or worse, shaming. I think a great leader knows how to empathetically listen to views or opinions they don't agree with, while also openly considering that other views may not be incorrect.
ReplyDelete