Wednesday, June 30, 2021
Does gossip has more to say about the talker than the target?
A plan for your next Birthday
Did Benjamin Franklin write his Autobiography because he was proud of his emergence from “Poverty and Obscurity” to one of “Affluence and some Degree of Reputation” or did he do it to pass on the lessons and experiences from his life to his children as an act of coaching? Or did he just love writing and did so because he had a great story to tell? We’ll never know his real motivations, but we’re all better off knowing what his brilliant “polymath” mind thought and considered.
Ben Franklin talks proudly about how he used his time at sea when sailing back to America to make a “Plan” and that too at a very young age and which he faithfully adhered to through old age. It’s powerful and transformative to be able to plan and have an idea of how you’d like your entire life to turn out. Eisenhower’s famous quote comes to mind “Plans are nothing; planning is everything”. While plan may change, the act of planning engages the conscious and subconscious mind in powerful ways that shape and influence our future and how we prioritize our time,
If there was one thing I would go back in the past and change, it is planning early in my career. For a lot of my career, I did not plan, have long term goals or take steps towards those goals. Rather, I just went with the flow and before I knew it, decades had passed. It was very late in my career that I paused from the hectic pace of the daily grind to reflect and plan on what I really wanted to do and how I wanted to spend the rest of my life. This is one lesson I emphasis as I coach my kids and my teams. Just so this act of conscious evaluation, reflection and planning for my future happens on a regular cadence, I now take my Birthday's off, for a day of reflection and planning. This is the same advice I give to all those I coach.
Now, my Birthday's are when I plan not only for the next year but for as far ahead as I can. In todays fast changing world, I also use this opportunity to assess my skills, to determine what I need to build and add on the next year. The HES program I’m in and this class I’m taking are a result of one such Birthday plan from 2017!
An interesting study from the McKinsey Global Institute on the Future fo Work uncovers some of the skills we may need looking forward (see graphic). Some of these are going into my next birthday “Plan”.
Truth doesn't matter
Yesterday night discussions in our group session, we had a very interesting chat about social media and the impact it could have on leadership. For the sake of this post, I will focus only on high-profile leaders such as politicians, activists, influencers and others whose impact is destined to a broad public.
Leaders must have ways to reach their followers. Otherwise, they won’t be leading anything more than themselves. In Adam Smith’s time, a parade in the streets once a year and a few public prayers would be enough. In today’s society, our screens act like a microscope on those who we admire and allow us to crown or to condemn whoever we want. Social media gives a voice to everyone. Not only everybody can express what they think and be heard, but you can also be sure that whatever you do, you’ll get even more retroaction than you could ever want or need. And we know so well how kind, but also how violent it could get sometimes. It is probably the greatest nightmare of the Tradesman coming true.
So again, in this context that can bring nothing else than cynical insight on our society, leaders still must have ways to reach their followers. And there is simply no way you can do without internet these days. Full disclosure, I am 23 years old, and I never lived in a world without internet. Just like a majority of people my age, I don’t have cabled television, I’m not listening to radio and the only thing I read from newspapers are few random articles that I happen to scroll on my facebook feed everyday. All these traditional medias that allowed leaders to inform their followers or charm the public have literally no effect on me, and probably very little on all people my age in general. Why should I wait two hours for the TV to show me news that probably don’t interest me when I can find whatever relevant and interesting information in a few seconds on my phone?
And in fact, these media simply don’t suit the cynism of my generation. In 50 years from now, it is me and my kids that will have to deal with climate change, more and more frequent pandemics, overcrowding and pollution. These leaders hidden behind their clean ties and their shallow promises won’t be there to deal with it, and the sight of their perfectly cured image on a TV screen is nothing else but a personal attack to so many people of my age. So when Facebook and Instagram allow me to have access to these same leaders in a more informal way through their stories or publications, no wonder why I am more prompt to consider them credible. Of course, I have an expectation for professionalism, leadership and proficiency. But this social media window gives me the impression that you are human, that you really care about me and that you will take action in my interest, even if we never spoke before.
I couldn’t help but notice yesterday that there seems to be a very generational aspect in the consideration of social media’s pros and cons. Indeed, there is a great danger associated to the use of social media, and so many ethical issues related to targeted publicity, quality and rigour of information and according attention to people who may not deserve it. But the truth is, truth doesn’t matter. Defoe was so right on this one, even more today. Cancel culture is here to demonstrate this: there is no place on cyberspace for those who lose the public’s esteem. The internet tribunal has no pity and lets his millions of jurors decide (mostly arbitrarily) what’s good and what’s bad. But, if I can quote Queen Elizabeth about her first appearance on TV, «that's what we do now».
And yes, I do understand the difference between fame and leadership. Especially on these platforms, we can see more and more often anonymous individuals do whatever random stuff they do and then become viral. Some of them will go right back in anonymity as fast as they became famous, but some will also realize their possible impact on people and, most importantly, their capacity of transforming these likes and shares into concrete human action. It is so impressive how someone, by a simple instagram story, lead thousands of people to give thousands and thousands dollars to a cause in a few minutes, or gather into one same spot, of eat Tide Pods just for fun. What would be more safe to say is that, as a first priority, we are looking for entertainment, and if the algorithms happen to show us by pure hazard someone who holds a true claim on leadership in who we recognize ourselves, we may mobilize into action. So then, for aspiring leaders, it is all about knowing how to show themselves in the middle of what is perceived as good and what the public wants to see. There is this very thin line between the «politically correct audacity» that you can show without being sent to the gallows and the clean image that made all these traditional leaders lose the interest and esteem of people my age.
My father once told me when I was a kid that I can use a knife, even if it may cut me. The most important is to be careful while using it and to develop my skills with it so that it won’t be as dangerous for me, because if I want to be functional in the kitchen, I must learn how to use it. It is literally the same with social media. Defoe must return in his grave by seeing that his coffee houses and tea saloons have become international web platforms who reunite millions of gossipers every second. It is a very big challenge for a leader to take this risk to be seen in such a way, if only they esteem it is worth it after all. But to have a link with young adults, whom crowd grows more and more everyday, it is a price one must pay.
The Power of Vulnerability and Authenticity
Throughout Benjamin Franklin‘s autobiography I felt a large disconnect. I can’t help but think about the large parts of his life that are missing from these pages, the feelings he is not mentioning, and why are the connections with his family and friends not mentioned more. We all know of his great accomplishments throughout life, not necessarily from his autobiography, but from what others have wrote about him and his achievements. I want to know more about what makes him human, what struggles he faced, and what kind of connections he built with the people around him.
How did he feel when he was passed up for professional opportunities in the beginning of his career, What kind of mistakes did he make, what difficulties did he have as a child, were there subjects or topics he didn’t enjoy in school, was he able to create authentic human connections, what kinds of regrets does he have? Did he celebrate his achievements? Was his family proud of him, what wisdom did he pass down to his children? Maybe these topics are things that were frowned upon in writing during this time, but the disconnect I feel from old English writing makes it difficult to connect and apply to my professional growth. I find it strange he only mentions his family a few times throughout his autobiography. I feel his family had to have some type of impact on his success and lengthy list of achievements. It was hard to connect with this reading because I didn’t find authentic feelings behind the words.
Benjamin Franklin‘s leadership style seems to be highly professional and not personal, more technocratic and less charismatic. In today’s world I might compare him to a politician that seems far out of touch from the people and their needs. People need a leader that’s approachable, accessible, honest, and vulnerable. The people want a leader who is like them, like us, and understands/cares about what we want and need.
From reflecting on my past professional experiences, the leaders I felt most connected to are the ones that made me feel heard. These leaders took into consideration the employees ideas of how to be better, and correct concerns within the workplace. They gave constructive feedback in a manner that was caring and helpful, as opposed to blame and disappointed. These leaders also were open about their feelings, stress levels, the reality of meeting their goals, and setting expectations throughout the department. This openness displayed vulnerability and ownership of some of their weaknesses. Providing a sense of humanity and relatability. Creating this kind of connection builds respect and rapport from employees. No one is perfect, we all have our weaknesses, strengths, and being authentically vulnerable can help strengthen the relationship between bosses, managers, and employees.
I can relate to Ben Franklin in the fact that he wanted to portray himself in the best light within his autobiography, but I also believe that displaying the sense of humanity brings out a positive light as well. Showing he cared for his family and friends, while also staying focused on his career and ambitions, would enhance his leadership qualities and create and even better leader. If people removed the filters we used to portray and promote ourselves as who we want to be, maybe a heightened sense of connection could be created between us.
Characteristics of a Humble Leader
Mike Tyson Never Met Benjamin Franklin
“Perhaps the most important Part of that Journal is the Plan to be found in it which I formed at Sea, for regulating my future Conduct in Life. It is the more remarkable, as being form’d when I was so young, and yet being pretty faithfully adhered to quite thro’ to old Age.”
Planning is an important part of leadership. It involves defining
boundaries, performing internal and external assessments, creating and
conveying direction, having mission-specific strategic goals, and so on. While
it is possible to “wing it,” that approach is only successful with some
experience or luck, and carries with it a higher chance of failure. Football teams
have game plans that they follow, but often with on-the-fly and halftime
adjustments; the adjustments are part of the overall plan, and as such, with
planning comes flexibility. It is safe to say, generally, that no plan will
ever survive its initial implementation… unless it’s Ben Franklin’s plan. We
can call it flexibility, or adaptability, but whatever we want to label it, we need
that trait as leaders to succeed.
Do you find flexibility to be an important part of
leadership? Have you ever had a boss that wasn’t flexible? I’d love to hear
your thoughts!
Mike Tyson is credited with saying, “Everyone has a plan
until they get punched in the mouth.” But Mike Tyson never met Benjamin
Franklin.
Bad Bosses Inspire Employees to Leave
Reading about Benjamin Franklin's experience with Samuel Keimer brought back a few memories of an experience of my own from early in my career and I would like to highlight a few thoughts about bad bosses. For Franklin, having had some experience with Keimer, and then later in London hearing some negative things about him--including from Keimer's wife--he was already weary of taking the position at the printing house, however, it seems this was the remaining option Franklin had when other work did not materialize. Franklin soon found out in a rather public display of anger that Keimer's character was severely lacking, and promptly left his employment.
During my sophomore year of college I was enticed to join a de novo (startup) industrial loan company (captive bank) with a mentor of mine who would be serving as the CFO. With little formal accounting training--I think I had taken only my first financial and managerial courses--I would be working as a staff accountant with great prospects for growth and close mentorship from a seasoned CFO who had taken me under his wing. I was excited for what was ahead. Within a month the bank had hired a new Chief Executive/President who I came to quickly realize was going to be a challenge to work with. Hailing from South Africa with a significantly different world view than that of many employees in our small college town, there were early indicators that his temperament would be challenging (mostly based on some subtle discriminatory opinions he expressed--comments about women, religion and minorities to name a few.) I decided to be cautious in my interactions, and also tried to give him the benefit of the doubt.
Within about nine months several employees had quit, mostly after run-ins with the CEO. One woman walked out twice, another had been brought to tears on a few occasions, and my mentor seeing no great options to resolve some major conflicts also quit. This of course was unsettling, but I was being paid well and for a college student who had broken into his field of study well before graduating I didn't want to mess up a good thing.
A few months later my breaking point came when as a the sole resource remaining in the accounting department I became so saddled with mounting work and declining grades I decided to bring it to his attention that I would not be able to continue in the position--at least in the current capacity. I would need to take a lesser role, or I would need to quit. My timid and apologetic approach was met, as Franklin was, with a rather public, loud, and red-faced CEO in what I will always remember as the most unpleasant interaction I have ever had with a manager, to say the least. There was only one decision to make at that point and I collected my things and left.
There is of course more to this story than I've related here, however if you read between the lines you can see that the attitudes of this CEO were not conducive to a positive culture or effective employee relationships. While I'm sure many bosses, like Keimer, have had occasion (and maybe even good reason) to raise their voices I believe this should be the rarest of events, and has very little place in public hallways and offices. The manager that becomes a bully will soon be left without anyone to manage.
I look back now and can't find too many redeeming qualities about the bad bosses I have encountered, especially this CEO. I do not see them as leaders, simply people who were "in charge." It was not difficult to decide that there were more important things than working for such a volatile character who lacked real leadership ability.
Tuesday, June 29, 2021
The Price of Broken Pots
A short story, attributed to artists David Bayles and Ted Orland:
“The ceramics teacher announced on opening day that he was dividing the class into two groups. All those on the left side of the studio, he said, would be graded solely on its quality. His procedure was simple: on the final day of class he would bring in his bathroom scales and weigh the work of the “quantity” group: fifty pounds of pots rated an ‘A’, forty pounds a ‘B’, and so on. Those being graded based on ‘quality’, however, needed to produce only one pot - albeit a perfect one - to get an ‘A’. Well, came grading time and a curious fact emerged: the works of highest quality were all produced by the group being graded for quantity.”
The authors go on to point out that the quantity group excelled because of the iteration. Iteration demands a certain amount of diligence and hard work - a theme that unmistakably threads through the material we study.
Walter Kirn notes that in the eyes of Buffet, “the ideal corporate leader is someone who grabs hold of his own bootstraps and never stops pulling up, no matter how far he rises.” This is a powerful vision of failure and resistance being surmounted through pure willpower and hard work.
Defoe points out “nothing can give a greater prospect of thriving to a young tradesman, than his own diligence” and emphasizes that business requires constant attention and focus:
“[trade] must be followed with the full attention of the mind, and full attendance of the person; nothing but what are to be called the necessary duties of life, are to intervene; and even those are to be limited so, as not to be prejudicial to business”
As mentioned in class, the same tool of iteration can be applied to the work of becoming a more effective leader. Since lasting success requires iteration, it’s clearly a powerful and relevant tool - but at what cost? In the example drawn out by Bayles and Orland, the pottery is presumably paid for and the hastily hewn vessels have little downside. However, in our own lives, our failures are rarely so free. Increasingly, our digital lives are documented and preserved forever in a tangle of distributed vaults. Despite calls for the right to be forgotten, past activity - regardless of interest - is rarely beyond recall.
That effect seemingly makes the work of a brave future leader ever-more challenging. Not only does one need to carefully craft and control a current image, but an effective leader seemingly needs to account for an increasingly high resolution and impartial historical account of every action that they have taken. On the surface, this seems like a positive effect as a watchful eye may encourage good behavior. However, could it also have a chilling effect, and reduce iteration?
Do you trust me to play the Latin card?
When you hear the word "credit," what do you think of? Perhaps it's your FICO score, leverage, debt or submitting an application for a student loan or mortgage. Fun Latin fact -- and, really, aren't all facts about Latin fun? -- credit is derived from the Latin word, credo, which means trust.
If you haven't already drifted off to sleep, you might wonder why I would know such a thing and where the connection to leadership lies. Full disclosure: in addition to "carpe diem" and "caveat emptor," the Latin factoid I just threw down was all I've got. I never studied Latin but, early in my career, I went through credit training, as all corporate bankers do, and it started with defining credit.
Daniel Defoes's "The Complete English Tradesman" included a section called, "Of Tradesmen Ruining One Another by Rumour and Clamour, by Scandal and Reproach." Defoe talks about credit being the "choicest ware" a tradesman deals in, and that slander and rumor can impact one's standing with creditors. Credit certainly facilitates trade and cash flow. Since the extension of credit is based on trust, however, is it a stretch to say that trust is the foundation for trade? And that slander and rumor affect trust?
Can you picture the 18th century tea-table and coffee-houses in which rumors may have been exchanged? Defoe felt compelled to point out how idle chatter, possibly based on nothing more than envy, led to the ruin of one author and a number of Lombard Street banks. He called this "trading murder."
Fast forward to 2021, I'm not sure whether the tea-table ladies are still around (or I'm persona non grata -- hey, more Latin!), but we certainly have our share of Starbucks and Peet's. And people do gather there to chat. If Defoe was concerned about cross-table chatter, can you imagine what he would have said about Yelp, lawsuits, viral videos, texting, etc.?
While I appreciate Defoe's idealism, that we can repair the world if we avoid spreading false rumors about one another, I fear that train left the station some time ago. It remains true today that rumor and slander can affect trust and credit. So, what should a leader do to be neither the supplier nor subject of gossip?
Here's my take. If you want mutual trust, create it. Do you, first, trust yourself to make what Adam Smith called praiseworthy choices? Second, do you trust your people? In I/O Psychology, we learned about Douglas McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y. When a leader believes workers are lazy and can't be trusted, this belief will cause a different set of actions from a leader who believes that her workers are inherently good and trustworthy. Third, do you trust your customers and suppliers? Do your dealings with these counterparties create or crater trust in you and your organization?
It's often said that trust takes time to build and a moment to ruin. As a leader, what actions do you take to build credo, or trust?
Monday, June 28, 2021
Do people expect things of Lord Sandwich now that they didn't before?
Do people expect things of Lord Sandwich now that they didn't before?
As the 11th Earl of Sandwich explains, the world has evolved, and having a title today no longer has the same implications as during the first generations of the family.
As we have learned in class, a good leader must take into account social expectations to navigate and manage them in his favor. So what allowed the 4th Earl of Sandwich to get involved in business and trade? I think that more than a change in people's expectations, what changed is how lords are perceived through the ages. Before, they had more significant influence and leadership over people; therefore, they had greater social expectations. So could it be that the 4th Earl can do business simply because he is no longer that important and people just don't care?
So, answering the initial question. I don't think people expect things from the lord that they didn't expect before; I believe that, on the contrary, due to the loss of significance, they have simply stopped expecting several things that they previously expected from the aristocracy.
As he says, "There's no real security in simply being from an old family anymore" because the meaning of the family is no longer the same and therefore its influence on society and its demands on them.
Who Determines Reputation, Why them?
Why does our culture glorify gossip and slanderous banter of others? So many popular television shows and gossip columns are endorsed and recognized as one of the top entertainment choice for viewers. For example, “Pretty Little Liars” was one of the highest viewed TV shows by teenagers and young adults from 2010 – 2017. This show attracts viewers in with its murder mystery in trying to solve who killed Allison, who is A, and what is fabricated versus reality? The series was able to create 160 episodes worth of mystery and gossip for its loyal fan base that kept coming back
Another example of this addiction to deceit and curiosity within fallacies, is the book and television series, Gossip Girl. This show ran on glorified gossip, the sweetness of revenge, and mountains of secrets that could rip away the dignity of the even the most trusted and highly regarded individuals.
Why do we as people find untruthful and discriminating info so captivating? Do we really ever stop to think about how this fictitious gossip effects those around us, or how it can change the way someone perceives another person?
DeFoe points out how disastrous a small rumor can be, from evolving over time as small rumor to a life altering incident. In the words of DeFoe “So small a rumour will overset a tradesman, if he is not very careful of himself; and if a word in jest from himself, which though indeed no man that had considered things, or thought before he spoke, would have said (and, on the other hand, no man who had been wise and thinking would have taken as it was taken)--I say, if a word taken from the tradesman's own mouth could be so fatal, and run such a dangerous length, what may not words spoken slyly, and secretly, and maliciously, be made to do?”
Why do we individually want others to see us as a respectable, loyal, honorable, and trustworthy person, and then slander or misspeak of others who wish to be viewed in the same light? Do people realize the power within their words and their perceptions of others? This can be related to all aspects of ordinary life, but one major area where we want to be seen in high regard is in the workplace. We can control our own actions and prove our worth in the office with hard work ethic and charisma, but we are unable to control how our colleagues perceive us.
At least within hospitality, word of mouth spread like wildfire and rarely was the topic of conversation ever questioned in its accuracy. This led to many predetermined notions of others where employees did not take initiative to get to know people before creating their own opinions of others. This led to many toxic work environments and a high turnover rate at all of the event venues I worked for. Luckily at my new employer the managers do not partake in office gossip and we are all encouraged to meet with new colleagues individually to create an authentic connection. We are also encouraged to ask ourselves and others for feedback on how we work together to learn our own leadership and work styles. Teamwork, feedback, trainings, and practice is how my current department and employer form our professional and personal skills. I am eternally grateful to now see how continued education and learning from others enhances my understanding of how to grow and continue to become a better leader and person overall. I will continue to ask the question of "Why?" and follow the Golden Rule.
Adam Smith’s Instagram Model
In The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Adam Smith draws out an explanation for why we fawn over kings instead of peasants and - applied today - might prefer to invest our attention in @arianagrande (227 million followers) instead of @ultrametazen (70 followers – my account – currently private). Smith argues that a robust and compelling force is not from rational self-interest, but rather that those who have obtained celebrity of interest appear as embodiments of our dreams and deeply held ambitions, and we connect strongly with them for that reason. Extending this explanation, we play a substantial role in the manifestation of those dreams by lending power to others - that symbolize them - through our attention and participation.
Even though Smith put pen to paper nearly three hundred years ago, his model of ambition still holds explanatory power today. While exclusive zoom calls might have replaced balls at Kensington Palace, we have not lost interest in looking up to – and participating in - stations of power, despite the associated cost. What might have changed is the subtle social roles – or at least the mapping is less clear on my side.
Who is more like a classic monarchical king, a widely known social media influencer, or a democratically elected president? Could a modern-day president even be elected without a substantial social media presence?
Regardless, Smith’s model appears to be generic enough to make it sound even if the nuances and specifics of our social structure have evolved.
Correspondingly, it would probably come as no surprise to Smith – if he were alive today - that over half of young Americans are interested in becoming an influencer, given the opportunity:
| From a 2019 Report Produced by Morning Consult |
This might be a surprising outcome. However, if both King and Influencer reflect the most extreme form of our deeply held ambitions, then Instagram is just a modern-day platform supporting the same patterns of human behavior that have been happening for thousands of years. Under Smith’s model, we should not be surprised that our children want to be (and promote) influencers, just as we should not be surprised that they would like to be happy.
Public domain portrait of Adam Smith obtained from Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Adam_Smith_The_Muir_portrait.jpg). Original oil painting is in the Scottish National Gallery, PG1472.







