Wednesday, June 30, 2021

Truth doesn't matter

Yesterday night discussions in our group session, we had a very interesting chat about social media and the impact it could have on leadership. For the sake of this post, I will focus only on high-profile leaders such as politicians, activists, influencers and others whose impact is destined to a broad public. 

Leaders must have ways to reach their followers. Otherwise, they won’t be leading anything more than themselves. In Adam Smith’s time, a parade in the streets once a year and a few public prayers would be enough. In today’s society, our screens act like a microscope on those who we admire and allow us to crown or to condemn whoever we want. Social media gives a voice to everyone. Not only everybody can express what they think and be heard, but you can also be sure that whatever you do, you’ll get even more retroaction than you could ever want or need. And we know so well how kind, but also how violent it could get sometimes. It is probably the greatest nightmare of the Tradesman coming true. 


So again, in this context that can bring nothing else than cynical insight on our society, leaders still must have ways to reach their followers. And there is simply no way you can do without internet these days. Full disclosure, I am 23 years old, and I never lived in a world without internet. Just like a majority of people my age, I don’t have cabled television, I’m not listening to radio and the only thing I read from newspapers are few random articles that I happen to scroll on my facebook feed everyday. All these traditional medias that allowed leaders to inform their followers or charm the public have literally no effect on me, and probably very little on all people my age in general. Why should I wait two hours for the TV to show me news that probably don’t interest me when I can find whatever relevant and interesting information in a few seconds on my phone?


And in fact, these media simply don’t suit the cynism of my generation. In 50 years from now, it is me and my kids that will have to deal with climate change, more and more frequent pandemics, overcrowding and pollution. These leaders hidden behind their clean ties and their shallow promises won’t be there to deal with it, and the sight of their perfectly cured image on a TV screen is nothing else but a personal attack to so many people of my age. So when Facebook and Instagram allow me to have access to these same leaders in a more informal way through their stories or publications, no wonder why I am more prompt to consider them credible. Of course, I have an expectation for professionalism, leadership and proficiency. But this social media window gives me the impression that you are human, that you really care about me and that you will take action in my interest, even if we never spoke before. 


I couldn’t help but notice yesterday that there seems to be a very generational aspect in the consideration of social media’s pros and cons. Indeed, there is a great danger associated to the use of social media, and so many ethical issues related to targeted publicity, quality and rigour of information and according attention to people who may not deserve it. But the truth is, truth doesn’t matter. Defoe was so right on this one, even more today. Cancel culture is here to demonstrate this: there is no place on cyberspace for those who lose the public’s esteem. The internet tribunal has no pity and lets his millions of jurors decide (mostly arbitrarily) what’s good and what’s bad. But, if I can quote Queen Elizabeth about her first appearance on TV, «that's what we do now». 


And yes, I do understand the difference between fame and leadership. Especially on these platforms, we can see more and more often anonymous individuals do whatever random stuff they do and then become viral. Some of them will go right back in anonymity as fast as they became famous, but some will also realize their possible impact on people and, most importantly, their capacity of transforming these likes and shares into concrete human action. It is so impressive how someone, by a simple instagram story, lead thousands of people to give thousands and thousands dollars to a cause in a few minutes, or gather into one same spot, of eat Tide Pods just for fun. What would be more safe to say is that, as a first priority, we are looking for entertainment, and if the algorithms happen to show us by pure hazard someone who holds a true claim on leadership in who we recognize ourselves, we may mobilize into action. So then, for aspiring leaders, it is all about knowing how to show themselves in the middle of what is perceived as good and what the public wants to see. There is this very thin line between the «politically correct audacity» that you can show without being sent to the gallows and the clean image that made all these traditional leaders lose the interest and esteem of people my age. 


My father once told me when I was a kid that I can use a knife, even if it may cut me. The most important is to be careful while using it and to develop my skills with it so that it won’t be as dangerous for me, because if I want to be functional in the kitchen, I must learn how to use it. It is literally the same  with social media. Defoe must return in his grave by seeing that his coffee houses and tea saloons have become international web platforms who reunite millions of gossipers every second. It is a very big challenge for a leader to take this risk to be seen in such a way, if only they esteem it is worth it after all. But to have a link with young adults, whom crowd grows more and more everyday, it is a price one must pay. 

1 comment:

  1. I appreciated the discussion last night and your related thoughts here. The idea of social media platforms providing a rapid environment for iteration is interesting - although often times more in pursuit of vitality over veracity. Accordingly, I also get the sense that Defoe would not be pleased with the state of the world today.

    Human behavior fuels this problem and our technology only amplifies it. However, the same technology can be used to amplify our better traits as well ...if only they were as easy to commercialize.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.