When you hear the word "credit," what do you think of? Perhaps it's your FICO score, leverage, debt or submitting an application for a student loan or mortgage. Fun Latin fact -- and, really, aren't all facts about Latin fun? -- credit is derived from the Latin word, credo, which means trust.
If you haven't already drifted off to sleep, you might wonder why I would know such a thing and where the connection to leadership lies. Full disclosure: in addition to "carpe diem" and "caveat emptor," the Latin factoid I just threw down was all I've got. I never studied Latin but, early in my career, I went through credit training, as all corporate bankers do, and it started with defining credit.
Daniel Defoes's "The Complete English Tradesman" included a section called, "Of Tradesmen Ruining One Another by Rumour and Clamour, by Scandal and Reproach." Defoe talks about credit being the "choicest ware" a tradesman deals in, and that slander and rumor can impact one's standing with creditors. Credit certainly facilitates trade and cash flow. Since the extension of credit is based on trust, however, is it a stretch to say that trust is the foundation for trade? And that slander and rumor affect trust?
Can you picture the 18th century tea-table and coffee-houses in which rumors may have been exchanged? Defoe felt compelled to point out how idle chatter, possibly based on nothing more than envy, led to the ruin of one author and a number of Lombard Street banks. He called this "trading murder."
Fast forward to 2021, I'm not sure whether the tea-table ladies are still around (or I'm persona non grata -- hey, more Latin!), but we certainly have our share of Starbucks and Peet's. And people do gather there to chat. If Defoe was concerned about cross-table chatter, can you imagine what he would have said about Yelp, lawsuits, viral videos, texting, etc.?
While I appreciate Defoe's idealism, that we can repair the world if we avoid spreading false rumors about one another, I fear that train left the station some time ago. It remains true today that rumor and slander can affect trust and credit. So, what should a leader do to be neither the supplier nor subject of gossip?
Here's my take. If you want mutual trust, create it. Do you, first, trust yourself to make what Adam Smith called praiseworthy choices? Second, do you trust your people? In I/O Psychology, we learned about Douglas McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y. When a leader believes workers are lazy and can't be trusted, this belief will cause a different set of actions from a leader who believes that her workers are inherently good and trustworthy. Third, do you trust your customers and suppliers? Do your dealings with these counterparties create or crater trust in you and your organization?
It's often said that trust takes time to build and a moment to ruin. As a leader, what actions do you take to build credo, or trust?

Like we talked about in our section meeting, I think the tea tables and coffee houses of our day are Facebook, Twitter and TikTok (among many other social media applications). There are also other platforms including cable news channel talking heads, gossip magazines, and even sports commentators. It's an endless stream of commentary about celebrities, politicians, athletes and actors. They seek to 'Credit' as well as discredit based on the agenda of the day with the goal mostly consisting of stirring up controversy and setting up posts that allow rumors, trolling comments, and hearsay to build out a portrait of the subject with little to no true context. I have to wonder what Adam Smith might think of these systems and pundits, or if it would just further solidify his already negative theory?
ReplyDeleteMichael,
ReplyDeleteAs always, I really enjoy reading your thoughts. But let's not forget "veritas."
Building trust can be difficult, especially when taking different contexts and framing into account. It's obviously one thing to build trust with a new coworker versus creating and maintaining trust with the public. This is a topic that we could discuss for weeks, maybe more. I think a few of the key points to trust are being authentic, being transparent, and being approachable (sure someone can be transparent, but if you can't approach them, do you trust them?). One final thought, trust can take years to build up and only seconds to break down, and violating trust can be irreparable.
Thanks for the thought provoking comments and questions.
ReplyDelete> So, what should a leader do to be neither the supplier nor subject of gossip?
The supplier portion is seemingly easier. We are in control of our actions and can simply reduce the amount of information that we distribute that could be considered slander or gossip. I appreciated your comments about the creation of mutual trust in line with this idea.
The other side - not being the subject of gossip - is obviously more challenging. In class, it was mentioned that maybe you can't be a person of fame or notoriety and escape gossip altogether. That gossip is a necessary side effect of not being anonymous.
If this is true, then influencing how people talk about you is key. Of course, your comments about mutual trust are highly relevant here as well. Those that you have built mutual trust with will not be quick to accept false rumors about your character.
However, is this a scalable approach? If not, are there other proven ways to build or modify a public image to make it durable against slander?