Earlier this spring, I won an award at my university to reward my academic excellence, my leadership and my impact on my community. When the news came out, I was interviewed in the national newspaper, I gave two radio interviews and I received letters from two members of Quebec’s and Canada’s parliament to thank me for my contribution. Random people were calling at my parent’s house to congratulate them for my career or send me gifts, and I received probably more than a thousand messages from people I don’t even know for the majority.
If you ask me what I thought about all of this, I certainly believe this went so much out of proportions. I remember feeling a great confusion to be congratulated about something I do every day, because it was nothing special to me, it was simply my daily life. I felt slightly uncomfortable knowing I suddenly became an object of scrutiny from people I don’t even know. And the worst part is that these same unknown people pretended they knew me, or believed they had the right to express opinions on my professional choices. As an example, a lady I don’t know even told me that I’m better to come back to Matane and become a family doctor because I have a responsibility towards people from my hometown to do so. Believe me, I abstained to tell her I want to become a surgeon in Toronto, and especially that I am the only person I owe my success to…
During the newspaper interview, I asked the journalist why she chose me, what made her want to share my story and why she thought it was worth sharing. She simply told me: «people need stories, they need to feel good in this pandemic and want to be inspired by people whose lives makes them hope for the best. They want to know you, so just let them look at you, it’s the least you can do.» From what she said, she was implying that since I have a great path, it is my responsibility to endure the eye of the public and it was a lesser evil to simply accept that with success comes attention.
So when I read Boorstin’s critic, I found it very interesting, but also very severe to those heroes who lose their credibility at the moment they become popular, even if they did not ask for it. I am very far from considering myself a hero, but I am well placed to know that people’s attention is not something you can really control. In these days, the public eye is more avid than ever. The «legendary blurr» that came with our historical heroes disappeared in the profit of a scrupulous scrutiny that leaves no place to mysticism in the process of building a hero’s narrative. The eye of the public goes further, it needs to know what is behind all of our actions, like if there was a special recipe to imitate. Just like the journalist and most common people, Boorstin had no pity for «the misery of the rich and famous»: once the public chose someone to give their attention to, you become more of an object and you must handle it and consider this as a privilege.
The distinction between a hero and a celebrity is not the outcome, which is remotely the same, but the reason why someone is under the spotlight. I make a link between the Boostin’s celebrity and Smith’s rich man in the concept of vanity: «[…] vanity is always founded upon the belief of our being the object of attention in approbation.» You may want to be famous because you believe you deserve attention, but wanting to be a hero implies to become the best in a given situation, and sometimes I know some people can’t help but to excel at what they do, even if they did not ask for anyone’s opinion or comparison. And I can’t help to feel empathy to those people who constantly must deal with people’s attention when they did not asked for it. The media has a special care to give as much information as possible about people who accomplish enough greatness to have a place in the public eye. But who decides what is extraordinary is not always the same person who accomplishes the greatness itself.
However deep the emptiness of the public remains, it should not be someone’s fault if he receives attention without asking for it, and therefore his great acts should not be considered less impressive because he becomes popular. I would certainly not discredit someone who achieves great things and becomes able to appreciate the fame he’s given, that is actually the best of both worlds. Someone whose only motivation is to be famous for the purpose of it is probably the most empty of us all, and deserves nothing more than compassion (or pity?) from people who were able to find meaning in more self-governing ways. And we should also understand that our unhealthy curiosity is probably has become the reason why true heroes are so rare to find these days.
The look of the others is the price to pay to be great these days. And oh, how heavy this weight can be.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.