Wednesday, July 21, 2021

Willingness to follow despite questioning the decision?

 As I watched and listened to our classmates' presentation on Ernest Shackleton, my husband came in the room and asked, "Did someone pick Shackleton for their leader? Interesting choice considering he killed everyone." I looked at him questioningly expecting him to launch into some sort of a Donner Party type explanation, when he simply remarked that it was just a bad choice. 

The group touched on this during their Q&A portion, questioning the morality of bringing people into a knowingly dangerous situation. Mike made the point that the crew that embarked on the mission with Shackleton were warned by him that "they might not come back alive." Still people joined the mission because they trusted Shackleton as a leader, as an explorer, and as an adventurer. I couldn't help but think at what point does bestowed leadership cross a line?

We see it often when speaking of cult leadership. People blindly following one person's teachings to their own detriment (drinking the Kool-Aid, as just one example). I don't think I am ready to throw Shackleton into the cult bucket just yet, but I do wonder what makes a leader so compelling that people would knowingly risk their own life to be one of his chosen? 

Is it charisma? Is it a need or want to be part of the lore? Blind faith? Confirmation bias?

4 comments:

  1. Katie,

    This is a really interesting topic. At what point does someone say, "I'm not going to follow you through the gates of hell!" There's actually an HBS case study on Mount Everest and decisions that team leaders made in 1996. If I recall correctly, two teams with varying degrees of expertise attempted the climb at about the same time. There were warning signs that the weather would be bad; ultimately it was deadliest season in Everest climbing history (at the time - it's now the third deadliest). If you can't pull up the HBS study, more info can be found at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1996_Mount_Everest_disaster. Thanks for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree, and I think this might hint at the influence of culture on charisma, or at least the cultural limits of charisma. Our world is very different now and a modern day Shackleton might have more difficulty in finding followers for the same perceived risk.

    Although, to complicate my own argument, we do have a modern-day parallel. Bezos, Branson, and Musk are prominent leaders working on private exploration into the modern day version of the Antarctic: space. The related participants - voyagers into space - are possibly helped along by the charisma of these leaders. So maybe little has changed after all.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you for sharing, Katie!
    Charismatic leaders like Shackleton have this amazing talent to make us believe we take part of something greater than us. The truth is probably between the ability of someone's ability to empower people or make them feel wanted and the need of some people to give meaning to their own lives. Participants in Shackleton's expeditions probably were not following him blindly and knew the risks, but they may have felt the need to accomplish themselves on something. And Shackleton, if subject to be put in the bucket of cult, was cultivating a fascination more about the journey in the north than about himself, which differentiates hm from a guru (I guess).
    I wanted to ask the team about the way people were selected to participate in the expedition. Were there people who participated in more than one expedition? Who were the type of people in there? Knowing this would probably give a better idea of their motivations to follow him in such a dangerous adventure.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Shackleton's newspaper advertisement is actually quite well-known. I'm surprised it wasn't shared in the presentation: "Men wanted for hazardous journey, small wages, bitter cold, long months of complete darkness, constant danger, safe return doubtful, honor and recognition in case of success."

    I think this says it all. The risks were clear, and so was the reward. I'm not sure what made so many raise their hands except the prospect of "honor and recognition" outweighed nearly certain death. Maybe that's why Elizabeth Holmes got so much money? The backers were willing to lose big for a chance they might be backing a world-changing technology.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.