Tuesday, July 13, 2021

Leadership That Gets Results


The dominant leadership styles of Obama and Clinton stand out even in the brief selections from the Jan 15th, 2008 Debate for the Democratic Party nomination. Obama leaves no doubt that he is a Transformational leader and believes that the role of the President is to have a vision of where country needs to go. He see’s it as the presidents job to bring together the best people and spark debates on the big challenges we face in Healthcare, Energy, Wages, Jobs etc. He sees it as his role to communicate the vision and get people behind the changes needs to transform the country. Obama’s acknowledgement of his weaknesses of loosing papers and having a messy office and desk further attest to his character traits of not worrying about the details and focusing instead on the big picture. As Obama acknowledges, for such visionary and transformational leaders to be successful, they need a great team of people around them that can follow through and execute on their vision.  


Hilary on the other hand acknowledges the need for a vision, but sees the president as the CEO who’s primary jobs it is to run the country’s bureaucracy efficiently. Her dominant leadership style comes across as  Technocratic and Cohesive. In contract to Obama, I would image that she will be super organized and never loose a “paper” and I would imagine that her office and desk are always in top order.


Who is a better leader ? I’d say that it depends on the job and even the situation. At peace time, a visionary and transformational president may work best, but during a war, a cohesive and technocratic leader maybe more successful. Leaders who have the flexility to adapt their leadership styles to the situation as hand will be able to draw from the the strength of each leadership style to drive outcomes.


This reflection reminded  me of an HBR article I read a while back on “Leadership That Gets Results” by Daniel Goleman. Goleman’s research suggest that “the most effective leaders use a collection of distinct leadership styles - each in the right measure, at just the right time.”


Goleman’s Six Leadership Styles and the style in a phrase are below.


Coercive - “Do what I tell you”.

Authoritative - “Come with me”.

Affiliative - “People come first”

Democratic -  “What do you think?”

Pacesetting - “Do as I do, now”

Coaching - “Try this”

  

Each style works best in certain situations, a few examples are below. 


Coercive - In a crisis, to kick start a turnaround, or with problem employees. 

Authoritative - When a change requires a new vision, or when a clear direction is needed.

Affiliative -  To heal rifts in a team or to motivate people during stressful circumstances.

Democratic -  To build buy-in or consensus, or to get input from valuable employees.

Pacesetting - To get quick results from a highly motivated and competent team.

Coaching -  To help an employee improve long term performance or develop strengths.



3 comments:

  1. Anto, Thank you for this post and for bringing in the brilliantly relevant quote from Goleman. I would agree that the greatest leaders are able to adapt to the need of the situation. Being able to recognize when to change the dial and how much to turn it up or down is a trait that is not coachable. It takes not only a massive amount of self-awareness, but also humility to recognize the natural state of your style is not appropriate for a given situation. Oftentimes I think ego and pride prevent elected (or hired corporate) leaders from seeing and understanding the benefit of flexibility in style. It's hard to pivot in general, but I think fear of ruining progress, reputation, and success all play into the reasoning we don't often find leaders with high levels of adaptability.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anto, I agree with you that flexibility in leadership style is necessary in order to be most effective, however, knowing when to pivot between these styles is a more difficult task. For Obama and Clinton (and other politicians and hired corporate leaders) there seems to be much risk associated with that pivot. In the political world where some live and die by approval numbers and media opinion it seems to me that there is a calculated risk that might come with straying from the style that your supporters expect from you--even if there's a better approach to take.

    Another thought I had is which of these styles is better suited, or in the very least an easier pivot given the form of leadership you are most naturally inclined towards: charismatic like Obama, or technocratic like Clinton. I would think there are some of these styles that would be more of a stretch to embody given a person's natural leadership form.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anto,

    Great post! I'd like to talk briefly about your reference to President Obama and needing a team of great people around to follow through and execute on vision. It reminds me of the phrase "a chain is only as strong as its weakest link." As leaders, we can make decisions, steer ships, handle crises, and so on. But if the people around us are incompetent, then it makes our jobs that much harder. A team member that isn't on board detracts from the goal; instead of moving forward at a fast pace, we instead find ourselves having to go back and help people who are dragging us down. Thanks for sharing!

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.