What a throwback to the 1980’s - tobacco, leveraged buyouts, Carl Icahn and hostile takeovers! Although I’m aging myself by confessing that I read this book when it was published, it was fun re-reading this section — having survived that decade and now through a leadership lens.
Could there be a clearer example of “the coin of the realm” we discussed in Monday’s class than how Ross Johnson led? At different points, his currency included: flattery to gain influence among board members and other CEO’s; “naming gifts,” office space and secretaries to silence knee-capped executives; corporate perks (carrots) such as use of the company jet, limos, corporate apartments and expense accounts to buy loyalty; and high-profile terminations (sticks) to apply implied threats to those who would consider crossing him.
Defoe and Franklin would no doubt be horrified at the chasm between Ross Johnson’s two faces, how he put on a mask of “good ol boy” in Winston-Salem, for example, and when it suited his purposes, yet used hardball tactics to accomplish his goals.
I imagine Karl Marx would have enjoyed pointing to Mr. Johnson as a prime example of the power of money to distort his effectiveness as a CEO. Did he create shareholder wealth, or was he simply the same “shit stirrer” he proudly proclaimed himself to be, but simply with more power?
I think Johnson’s genius was to shrewdly sense the base desires of people he needed to move around and give it to them. Although John Paul has described empathy as reading the reaction of others, I see this as only part true. There is a distinction between sensing what people desire and caring about people. Knowing what others desire and using coins of the realm to seduce them into doing what they don’t want to do? That’s manipulation. Knowing and caring about what others want, and providing a bridge for them to get there, while also accomplishing the organization’s goals? That’s persuasion. Marx might grumble, but I bet even he could get behind this.
And, finally, there’s the small issue about where Johnson’s little bag of 'realm coins' came from. By virtue of his position as CEO, did he have the authority to give away these coins? Should he have? If you were an RJR Nabisco shareholder at the time, what value would you have felt you gained from these expenditures?

Michael, great insights here! I feel like I need to read the biography, or better yet the autobiography, of Ross Johnson in order to better understand how his experiences made him the person that he was and how he figured out how to use his 'realm coins' so well. I'd like to believe that he was an archetype of a certain era when some of the cigar-smoking, jet-setting, wheeling-and-dealing "good 'ol boy" behaviors (among others) were more acceptable than today. But you don't have to look back any further than 2019 and Adam Neumann of We Work to see that there is just something about guys like Johnson that attract attention and success, and build a powerful position. It also leads me to some troubling concerns about money and power. They provide great case studies to support some of the ideas we read from Marx. The truth is, by virtue of his position he surely felt he was entitled to spend those coins in order to build his fiefdom.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Curtis. Why is that?! Something about power and money seems to attract a subset of megalomaniacs!
DeleteMichael, thank you for sharing these insights! I found our conversation during section interesting surrounding the differences between manipulation and persuasion. Your differentiation between the two is correct in my mind, but I'd like to ask if you think the following is manipulation or persuasion. If a startup company asks you to invest $10,000 into their company and you reluctantly agree, at first this seems to be manipulation. The company promises you won't regret your investment and they have your best interest in mind. Then say the startup becomes successful and your investment doubles. Does this manipulation then change into seeming like more of a persuasion because the investment benefitted you in the end? I'm curious if manipulation and persuasion can change depending on the outcome, as I've been wondering the same for myself.
ReplyDeleteHi Cassie, Thanks for your comments and for posing the question. In sales for many years and now helping others do it, I pride myself on my honesty and worry at times whether I am fooling myself and am crossing the line from persuading to manipulating.
DeleteTo your question, if you ask me to invest and I decide to do it, that's my call. No manipulation. Now, if you guarantee I will make x% return (lying), or you're my boss and tell me that all senior managers in our company must do this (threat), you're manipulating me for your own personal gain.
Your thoughts?