We are fascinated with wealthy people because, as a capitalistic society, we decided that everything has a price. Just like Marx said, «the extent of the power of money is the extent of my power». This «mediation» allows someone to defy all constraints that we, common mortal, are submitted to: discomfort, time, wait, compromise, etc. What we own is what people see, and it’s what people see that guides them to develop their perception about us. We mentioned it many times in this class: leaders are under constant scrutiny. And since money is power, we are so curious to discover what one may do if he possesses it.
Since someone with money can afford whatever desire and need he may have, what about people who don’t own money? It appears these people have no choice but to bend the knee in front of these giants in the hope to become a little more like them. This probability is very unlikely, since infinite means bring infinite needs. But this seek for money is also about the desire to free us from their power to «buy us». I believe part of the fascination for these people comes from the fact that we all have a price, and they could probably buy us if they wanted (and were willing to afford us). Are we all buyable? At what point? And what is the level of wealth that allows us to be freed from others?
This brings me to question myself about the motivations that leads us to follow people, and what could influence these. Is someone less of a leader if he has to pay for people to follow him? We would probably have less esteem for a leader who has to pay for people to follow him. But a leader is someone who can give people what they want, or at least what they think they want. If it’s recognition, trust, power or empowerment, so be it. If it’s money in exchange of their fidelity, and people still choose to follow the lead, this should be a sufficient reason to call this leadership. That type of leader uses his resources to motivate people to follow him in both cases, isn’t it? Obviously, these resources are external to him, which may interfere with the supreme values we may have as a human such as honour, dignity and virtue. Coincidentally, these values are probably those that would have the highest cost to buy from someone. But whatever the motive is, the choice is deliberate, and the leadership remains whatever incites it.
Marx’s thesis was developed in an epoch when this notion of choice was probably less obvious. For normal citizen, opportunities were much rarer, conditions much harder and socioeconomic context was allowing extreme poverty in opposition with extreme wealth, with not much in between. But today’s society has allowed the emergence of middle class, fluid and innovative corporative structures, plenty of professions and so many original communication channels that allow anybody with an original idea to start his own project if he wanted. In other words, the roads to leadership are more numerous, but their pavement is mostly the same.
In the meantime, all we can do is admire/desire or fear those super powerful people and reflect on the potential stranglehold they could have on us. In such a system, is Jeff Bezos the equivalent of God? I would say no, but my answer only comes from my optimistic perspective about humanity, since I hope at least someone down this earth would have a price Bezos can’t afford. And what about those people, like Warren Buffet, who own billions and still don’t do much of it? We could only ask ourselves if we would be able to resist the «alienation» if we were in his position. Buffet still has power by the only possibility he has to get whatever he wants. After all, it’s not about the power of money, it’s about the power we give the money.
I automatically start thinking about how the security of a well paid job can keep us in work we don't enjoy, or with a company/under a leader that is maybe not worth the money. I, myself, fall prey to getting too comfortable in a job despite my constant complaints about a manager and the lack of respect purely for the reason that the money and bonuses are good enough to keep me complacent. It's probably not the healthy mindset, but it does make you wonder at what price do you allow yourself to be miserable?
ReplyDeleteVery relevant question about Bezos, especially as he prepares to slip the bonds of (mere mortal) gravity and head to space.
ReplyDeleteYet, to your broader point, the power wielded by Bezos (and every billionaire) is given by us. Bezos is at least in small part a billionaire because we really like free next day shipping on socks and pool floaties.
I find that part of our current society encouraging. In order to gain wealth most of the time you have to at least ostensibly provide something of value. However, the financial systems that reward wealth with more wealth are distressing.