The last readings we had in class made me think about inspirational leaders, but also about leaders who may are loosing their claim to leadership. Especially, I was thinking about Ellen Degeneres, the very famous TV show host, comedian and LGBTQ+ advocate.
For so many years, she has been presenting herself to the public as a very charismatic leader with a special sense of humour, a big heart to help people in need and a special dedication to be kind to one another. I remember admiring her so much for building such a huge fanbase, giving away so many gifts to random people and being so influential with celebrities while remaining so casual and friendly in her approach. But in the last year, it seems that she also had an amazing talent to hide who she truly is: capricious, rude, moody, disrespectful and even despotic. These adjectives were all revealed by people who worked for her, visited her talkshow or had the occasion to get closer to her on the other side of the TV screen.
The most disturbing here is the mismatch between the image of kindness she built for the public and the testimonies from her professional surroundings that claim the opposite. As it appears, everbody wants to get closer the her, but if you get too close, you only want to escape as far as you can. The wave of articles from former employees was also a great occasion to test the solidity of her fanbase. Some of course defended her and remained loyal, but we could also see her very solid image slowly crumble in the eye of the public. In the last year, it became more difficult to book very famous people, her show had less viewers every week and it was announced that it would have its last season next year.
People who worked for Ellen had no choice to deal with her behaviour, at least until before they found another job. But the viewers of her show and her social media followers are probably her only leverage to claim leadership, and these events were enough to sow doubt in the public’s mind. Just like Max Weber says, «the only basis of legitimacy for it is personal charisma, so long as it is proved; that is, as long as it receives recognition and is able to satisfy the followers or disciples.» And referring to Daniel Defoe, the cruel part is that even if these allegations were false, it would not even matter since the tiniest doubt has already been installed in the followers’ minds. People don't want the truth, they want unicity in the character, and this is where Ellen sadly failed to bring business into life.
Regarding all of this, if these rumors are true, it seems like Ellen demonstrated a complete lack of leadership. By backing up her behaviour with her only hierarchical authority, she lost the possibility of people following her because they believe in her, and not only because they need their paycheck. I could say she was a victim of the scrutiny of the public, but the truth is that she is probably more the victim of her own bad behaviour with people. After all, like Weber says, the basis of the claim to legitimacy lies in «the duty of those who have been called to a charismatic mission to recognize its quality and to act accordingly».

Isabelle,
ReplyDeleteThis is a very interesting dissection of misleading public personas of leadership that don't align with true selves. With this story of ED and other leaders whose true nature comes to light, I scratch my head wondering what kept people silent for so long? Is it just fear of someone wielding more power? Money-backed power? Fear of being called a liar?
I am sure many things play into why "followers" would help perpetuate her pristine reputation as a supporter and kind person. Maybe we all need be a bit more skeptical of truly charismatic leaders. At least the technocratic seem to lay it all out there... rigid, strict, rule followers that they are :)
Hi Isabelle, I enjoyed your insights here! It kind of makes me think of the Charles Barkley scenario from the first session. Maybe she thinks she can be whoever she wants off stage while maintaining her following. If Ellen had a sit down with Oprah, what would she say? Would she open up about her truth and say she's not always a nice person, but paid to be one during her show? I also haven't seen many formal apologies to her workers.
ReplyDeleteI watched a clip of the show following these allegations and Ellen blames other members of her staff for this and then mentions these people no longer work for the show. I found that portion of the show to be extremely inauthentic and like they were trying to pull the wool over our eyes. How many other people do we look up to with inauthentic leadership. It's sad to think about...
Ellen DeGeneres is an interesting case study in the importance of maintaining a congruent public and private personality and image and the fragility of reputation, even for established members of society. Your points about this divide are very relevant. It's also interesting that these gaps - between public and professional life - become liabilities and risks that can explode years later.
ReplyDeleteWhat's worse: a related spectacular flameout of reputation, or constant knowledge and fear that your real personality might be discovered?
One of many celebrities and public figures whose private behavior did not align with their public commentary. I have a controversial opinion about this because I think as observers/viewers we need to bring a more healthy skepticism and lowered expectations to the table. To put people on a pedestal will surely lead to us being let down by something. It's most disturbing when, like in Ellen's case, the violations seem to be so blatant and rude--the complete opposite of the picture we build of these people in our heads. True that everyone has a bad day, but our human bias goes beyond giving a benefit of the doubt to filling in our mental image of these people as perfect paragons of virtue and benevolence. We might consider that we do not actually "know" them and that we only see the persona many of them want us to see. Maybe that is a cynical way to view people/the world, but our lives are complex and we set ourselves up to be manipulated if we only take things for face value.
ReplyDelete