Sloan's remarks about Durant's management were extremely interesting and highlight an issue within corporations that still exists within the modern day.
We often fall back on the many attributes we have already walked through multiple times in this class when defining what we want in our leader. We look for intelligence, empathy, confidence, and charisma. All soft skill/traits that are hard to teach someone. We expect to have these things found naturally in our leaders. All of that is fine and good on paper, but oftentimes I think we fail to add some of those hard skills to the written list of qualities.
Alfred Sloan points to this gap directly in his description of Durant. Durant is romantic in his vision. He seeks people who can make the "dream" happen. He is very charismatic and a great businessman, but Sloan would argue, lacks some of those managerial skills that one really needs to be equipped with to grow a business to a greater level. Sloan admires Durant's intelligence and generous spirit, alongside his integrity and imagination. All things we still want in our modern leaders. However, he notes specifically the administration skills Durant lacks. Specifically, Sloan notes, " Important decisions had to wait until he was free, and we often made impulsively" (p.28).
This is a mistake I have seen at many levels of a company. It ties to a lack of concrete managerial skills and organization. It can make for unstable conditions within a workplace and an insecure workforce. Never knowing what the policy change might be, if a necessary change will even be made, and a sense of being micromanaged can all lead to dissatisfaction and stagnation of growth.
Maybe I am off the mark, but I am sure we have all experienced managers who possess these qualities. They aren't bad people or bad leaders, but there are gaps that need to be filled. A great leader, as Obama alludes to in the 2008 debate transcript, is able to bring together people, to rally the troops, and concede to those weaknesses so that qualified people can step in a build a strong team.
Hi Katie, Many thanks for your thoughtful post! We really need both kinds of leaders, don't you think? The right-brain thinker who sees opportunity where others see risk; and the left-brain thinker who brings order to ideation. Is it even possible to find someone who is great at both? And, even if you captured that unicorn, could they do both effectively at the same time? I think this is the reason that so many companies look for counterbalancing leaders -- to capture the best of both!
ReplyDelete