Monday, July 19, 2021

The Slippery Slope For Charismatic Leaders

  


In My Years with General Motors, Sloan talks about Durant as a Charismatic Leader who “inspired confidence in this character and ability”. Durant was a visionary and pioneer of the automobile industry in the United States.  As Sloan details meticulously, we see how being charismatic is great to start and build up a company, but is not enough to sustain a leadership position especially one that that has significant responsibility, like was the case for Durant as CEO of General Motors. 


Sloan gives us great insights and examples of Durant’s “casual ways” and "impulsive nature" with highly impactful decisions. His automotive genius and imagination got General Motors to great heights, but his charisma alone could not sustain GM in that position for long. Ultimately, he was forced to step down as the CEO by GM’s bankers and he died bankrupt.


Sloan’s leadership style in sharp constant was Technocratic and led to sustained success for him and GM. This even though he took over GM at time when GM faced “simultaneously an economic slump on the outside and a management crisis on the inside”. 


Sloan said, explaining his management style. “He must be absolutely tolerant and pay no attention to how a man does his work, let alone whether he likes a man or not. The only criteria must be performance and character. And that is incompatible with friendship and social relations. A Chief Executive Officer who has ‘friendships’ within the company, has ‘social relations’ with colleagues, or discusses anything with them except the job, cannot remain impartial—or at least, which is equally damaging, he will not appear as such. Loneliness, distance, and formality may be contrary to his temperament—they have always been contrary to mine—but they are his duty.”


Dan Ciampa in the HBR article, How Charismatic Leadership takes us too far, takes us through the five phases that take place as a leader’s charisma shifts from a positive to a negative quality. Reading Sloan’s account of Durant’s leadership at GM we can see this in action.


The first phase:  This phase Is characterized by the subtle sense on the part of followers that the leader does not want to be questioned. The leader starts to act like they are the smartest person in the room.


The second phase:  Sensing the leader’s diminished appetite for being questioned or challenged, followers begin to self-censor, asking fewer questions and no longer playing devil’s advocate. 


The third phase: A negative cycle in which compliments and agreement cause them to become overconfident. Leaders in this stage create their own sense of reality and become resistant to evidence that they may be incorrect. 


The fourth phase. Since the leader’s views and actions are the only ones that matter, followers reduce their willingness to be proactive.  


The fifth phase is characterized by people continuing to follow and ostensibly do only what is necessary but with a deep diminishment in enthusiasm and spirit.

 

Charismatic leadership is seductive for both the leader and the followers. Leaders should not be blind to the signs of going down these five stages. The relationship between leaders and followers is delicate and needs constant tending to remain healthy. Leaders who do not allow for feedback and dissent can risk failure for themselves and their organization. 


2 comments:

  1. Anto, thank you for your post and insights! While reading your post I thought about those leaders that are technocratically challenged. What kinds of trainings or programs can they attend to gain the skills they are lacking? Who can help them be better with these competencies? As people we are always growing and learning but how do you learn once you get to the top? Would companies benefit from having a couple leaders that oversee as either the technocratic or charismatic lead? I am curious because we all are stronger at one versus the other. Thanks again!

    ReplyDelete
  2. There seems to be a connection with psychological ego when it comes to charisma. We can probably all agree that most people we consider to be charismatic trend pretty high on the ego scale. So the phases Ciampra outlines in his article seem to track well with our personal experience. There is probably a boss or colleague that we've all worked with where we recognize our own perceptions following that path. I also think that the journey from admirer to unwilling follower more speaks to our ability to recognize the mortality and limitations of those who heavily rely on their charisma. As we recognize their lack of skill or ulterior motives, maybe we see something that seems inauthentic, we begin to see them just as normal people--who maybe, aren't all that different from ourselves except for their talent to connect and persuade.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.