Monday, July 19, 2021

On Parasocial Relationships and Authenticity

A frequent topic in our class discussions has been the concept of business for life and – more specifically - how to apply this concept with authenticity. Business for life is seemingly relevant to all topics in the course because it connects the course material – and each section - with our ever-present personal lives. If we are to become effective leaders, we need to efficiently reconcile the necessary steps with our own unique personalities and do so completely – not just on the clock.

Wednesday’s guest speaker, Karen Tiber Leland, highlighted the carefully composing of reconciling business and personal branding, noting that our image across both dimensions should harmonize and we should be careful not to have discordant messaging because of the questions that it might raise. If I remember correctly, Karen cast this in a hopeful and positive light indicating that our combined personal and professional brands should yield a result that is greater than the sum of its parts.

Technology has provided an effortless platform for us to share our professional and personal thoughts – at incredible scale and our current world rewards sharing. Combining these forces and capabilities, we live in a world that encourages congruent personal and professional lives that are shared openly with the world at regular frequency and appears to favor those with the highest frequency and most intimate level. Taken to an extreme, our personal life becomes the essence of our professional life and spaces for truly private moments and thoughts are reduced significantly – turning all our lives into a low-viewership reality TV series of sorts. In this world, the lines between our followers, customers, and friends dissolve.

In such a world, how could we possibly establish and maintain relationships with those around us? A recent post in Cybernaut investigates this phenomenon and provides a model for looking at this mode of communication:

In 1956, Donald Horton and Richard Wohl coined the term “para-social relationship,” defined as a “seeming face-to-face relationship between spectator and performer.” … Their description of parasocial relationships—penned over six decades ago with Hollywood stars, television actors, and radio hosts in mind—feels like it was written about the current crop of online creators: the gamer hosting nightly streams, the podcaster dropping a new episode every Tuesday, or the daily vlogger revealing their morning routine. 

(https://every.to/cybernaut/the-blurred-lines-of-parasocial-relationships)

Maybe modern celebrities - in the framework of Horton and Wohl - have something to teach us about how to build and maintain these relationships in our combined personal and professional lives.

This is an area that I struggle with, especially as it relates to authenticity. If I share genuine content about my life – but do so using a psychological model designed to maximize engagement and my own success under the model above or similar – am I authentic? More importantly, am I a good citizen, friend, and business owner?

3 comments:

  1. Rob, I laughed out loud reading your post as it rings so true. Loved the analogy of a leaders life today to a "low-viewership reality TV series" The question you pose is great, are we "acting" to influence our viewers or are we being ourselves? The line is blurry for sure. I've personally stopped using the phrase "work-life-balance" and instead just use "life-balance" to reinforce for me that Life is more important that work and that I need to find a way to fit work in without disrupting my life, not the other way around. Thank you for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Rob,
    This was a great post, and I agree with Anto that it "rings so true." I don't know that I would necessarily subscribe to believing that the modern celebrity has it right. I would prefer to have them demonstrate further boundary creation (or respect) rather than continue down this path of blurring the lines between professional and personal. I agree that the divergence between those two lives should not be so vast as to contradict one another, but at what point do I lose my private life? I would rather be genuine in my personal life and have a slightly restricted version (maybe less cussing) for my professional personality.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I really understand your dilemma, Rob. From what I understood of the concept of authenticity, there's this importance in the concept of timing. And I don't believe that being strategic is an obstacle to authenticity. When Franklin made sure he was seen with his barrel by the most people in the street, was inauthentic because he planned his expedition, even if it was something he truly wanted to do and was authentic by doing the task in itself?

    The real challenge happens for people who built a strong persona for their professional life that is +/- different from their private personality. Those influencers who speak/walk/act a certain way in front of a camera certainly struggle to maintain unicity and show their authentic self, and this is probably why a lot of celebrities develop mental illness over time. But in fact, if your goal is simply to be yourself and not «give a show» all the time, you can still be authentic and show you out there by remaining the same person in all spheres of your life. You can share genuine content and show your true self in your interactions, and remain authentic even if you choose what you are showing to people. It won't be less true, you'll just be smarter I guess.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.