Wednesday, July 14, 2021

Leadership, Status, and Power. When do You Cross the Line?

Did anyone else look up the current cost to join the Lost Tree Country Club? It’s a $30,000 non-refundable application fee, and a $208,800 initiation fee.

Reading Barbarians at the Gate, it didn’t take long to realize that Ross Johnson is ambitious. He works hard, he rises to the top of companies, he builds a strong followership, and he keeps going up. It is truly impressive.

But I keep thinking about a theme that we allude to in class a lot, which is the reason for becoming a leader. I imagine everyone has slightly different motivations, internal and external pressures, unforeseen circumstances, luck, etc. To simplify things, I think it’s easy if we look at categories like leadership itself (“I care about this organization and its people”), status (“I want people to know I wield political influence”), and power (“I can personally make things happen”); I’m just spitballing these terms, I’m sure a deeper dive could provide better explanations.

I feel like Johnson crossed the line from leadership over to power. Perhaps if we look at motivation like a scale, it tipped, heavily, on the side of power. I don’t know how much he cared about the organization and the people he worked with, so much as he did gaining power and status. ‘That guy from the merger company can be screwed over if it means I can have my country club membership.’

I also don’t think these categories are mutually exclusive, and I don’t begrudge anyone who wants membership at that club. But I do think Johnson crossed ethical lines (he certainly did things I wouldn’t have, but then again, I’m not in that business) to be able to claim status and power. I’d love to hear your thoughts! Thanks.

3 comments:

  1. Thank you Pete for these great thoughts.
    Veblen (the same who wrote about absentee ownership) had also plenty of insights about this conspicuous consumption. He described very well the Veblen effect, this satisfaction coming from ostentation, about how you feel rich and powerful by showing you are with materialistic goods. In such a context, I believe it would be considered normal, or even good, to cross the lines of propriety and extravagance, because when you believe you can have everything, you also believe you can do everything you want as well, even if it’s non-enthical.

    I am really not trying to defend him, or to agree with him. But I think this intoxication with ostentation and power could be one legit explanation of his behaviour (but of course, not a justification). Johnson could also claim that all of this has a utility to reinforce that power he has, and that it was beneficial to (some) people around. And then, we come back to that discussion we had yesterday night in section group: does the end justify the need?

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your post reflects an important question about the costs of the techniques and approaches that could lead to short-term success and power. In some capacity, following in the Machiavellian footsteps of Johnson may not be out of reach for many of us - but the side effects would give us pause.

    I wouldn't be surprised if Johnson has a code of ethics, but it was challenging to discern from the assigned chapters. Johnson seems to care more about just money - the end of the last chapter makes that clear - but that has seemingly little bearing on his behavior.

    To what degree should we light on fire our future reputation, and the well-being of others around us, to enable an ascent to power and fortune?

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.