I found very interesting to read Veblen’s text and his virulent criticism about how we downgraded creativity and innovation to idolize «alert patience, moderation, assurance, and conservatism». Not only was created a persona deprived from contact with the people, but we also began to consider his work as «the most meritorious and the most necessary work to be done in this country». How curious it is that «the illusions of nationalism allowed the underlying population to believe that the common good was bound up with the business advantage of these captains of solvency [… and] that all the powers must work together for the benefit of the business interests of the larger sort. » Not only knowledge, morality and human qualities were set aside in our conception of a leader, but we also began to worship and ease the path of these captains to leadership and success. If Adam Smith read Veblen’s text, he would probably think we fell in a «corporative distorsion» causing great privilege to Captains of industry and misery to underlying population. But really, what happened? Is this the precursor of us being governed by computers?
It made me think that no matter what, humanity can never go without having figures of power, and just like we spoke about in class, the coin of the realm decides who takes the crown. War heroes, royalty, religious figures, intellectuals or bourgeois; we always had leaders that reflected the great challenges of an epoch. Those who hold the power were those who were able to meet the fundamental needs of population, whether it is physical protection, moral guidance, spiritual hope, critical knowledge or material security. The Captain of industry emerged in a time when we were trying to keep up on the ecstatic development of new technologies. At that moment, we reached a moment when the need was not to develop new technologies, but to know how to manage them and translate them in a productive context, which in fact requires no creativity, intelligence or particular emotional skill at all.
The bad news is that we are heading right into a period of uncertainty. For the first time in history, it seems like we are not heading to better times ahead of us. Climate change, overcrowding, pandemics, deforestation, pollution. We observe a shift between the generation who was born in a time that worshipped capitalism, success in wealth and overconsumption, and the generation that will have to deal with the problem created by these values.
Not so long ago, great financial figures were almost unanimously admired, which was actually fair. They had all the conditions to be considered successful leaders in a world that had money as the gold standard to measure success. But even if the fascination remains, those figures slowly but surely gain criticisms and lose followers that identify them as incarnations of a sick society that failed to create a better future. My speech probably makes me sound like I have pessimistic (and communist!) tendencies, but believe me, that would be my greatest nightmare. Nevertheless, I observe that my generation is divided between that desire to succeed in the financial way their parents worshiped and that despise of participating in unsustainable lifestyles that will probably cause the most harm to their own kids. It’s also this context that allows the emergence of leaders like Greta Thunberg who carries with her the worries of the next generation.
Those great problems appeal for great solutions, and the new set of values that is currently building brings this need for adaptativity, inventivity and humility. In this matter, leaders of tomorrow are probably more like Veblen’s workmanship leaders: «a man of workmanlike force and creative insight into the community’s needs, who stood out on a footing of self-help, took large chances for large ideals, and came in for his gains as a due reward for work well done in the service of the common good».
Will we assist to the greatest comeback in history?

This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIsabelle, thank you for this insightful and raw post! It's heartbreaking what humanity deems as important or inspiring. When will people realize we've gone too far? These undeniable global issues you mention of climate change, overcrowding, pandemics, deforestation, pollution can all be slowly corrected if we begin acting on these issues now. We keep pushing our problems off on future generations and sadly soon enough it will be too late.
ReplyDeleteI love how you said "Those great problems appeal for great solutions". Now it's time for people to start taking initiative and tackling these global issues. I greatly appreciate your insight Isabelle and it has been a pleasure working with you throughout this class!