Sunday, July 11, 2021

Veblen's 'Absentee Owner' is Alive and Well Today


Part of this week’s reading was Thorstein Veblen’s Absentee Ownership. Published in 1923, this book was written by a man who clearly has an issue with capitalism. Part of his thesis made me want to throttle him, put him in a shipping container and send him to Russia or China. Yet, if you’ve heard about a little thing called income inequality, there was another part that is relevant today.

Even if you’re a capitalist, as I am, you recognize the economic progression he describes: adventurer (founder) to captain of industry (manager/engineer) to captain of business (corporation) to captain of solvency (conglomerate). Can you imagine getting Veblen in the same room with a Morgan, Rockefeller or Vanderbilt?

For our many problems, I still believe that America offers the best platform in the world for a smart, hardworking person to find, start, finance, manage and sell whatever their chosen hustle.

But, then it dawned on me: the absentee owner is not some historic relic; not only is he still with us today, but he is even bigger, more admired and more powerful than what Veblen imagined. Today’s absentee owner is called Private Equity (PE). You may have friends that excelled at school and were fortunate enough to get a job at a PE firm, with starting bonuses and promises of significant gains.  Good on them, right?

The partners of large PE firms like Blackstone, Citadel and KKR are far removed from the creation or production line of their "portfolio companies," they take significant ownership positions in other people’s companies — largely financed with others’ money (a twist that would have made Veblen scream), hire former managers as operating partners to manage the technical aspects, and through financial engineering create mind-blowing gains for themselves over a 5-7 year target period.  Sounds a lot like how Veblen described his captain of solvency, don't you think?

They gain admiration through their ranking on the "world's richest" lists; the money they donate in the form of campus buildings, labs and professorships; and the money they spend on fantasy lifestyles replete with private islands, mega-mansions, personal 757's and mega-yachts. They gain power through political donations and access, which allows them to influence our country’s laws and even our relations with other countries.

So, are our current-day absentee owners a force for good or bad?  As I much as I don't want to, I agree with Veblen on this point in saying absentee owners are a negative force.  As a capitalist, I support the principle that creators, true entrepreneurs, should enjoy the benefits of their brilliance and hard work.  As it relates to PE firms, however, though some of their gains are shared with their investors -- who are overwhelmingly pension funds, higher education and wealthy families -- this is at best an indirect route to addressing the massive wealth gap in our country.  They don't build new businesses or technologies, innovate or, in most cases, create new jobs.  And, because of their political influence and access to the best advisors, they pay taxes on their gains at a lower rate than they should and, given the consistent assault on the estate tax, will ensure their wealth largely stays in their family.  What's worse, I resent that -- due only to their massive wealth -- they have more say than "we the people" in influencing our domestic and international policies.

What do you think about today's absentee owners? If you strip away all their wealth, are you comfortable that a PE mega-billionaire shares your interests?  How do we even fix this?

2 comments:

  1. PE firms are a great example of absentee owners. However, I probably would fall short of saying they are negative forces. Conceited and condescending? Sure. That's been my personal experience anyway, but there are some major positives the structure and existence of PE firms. I resent the putting dollars to work for the sake of getting them off the balance sheet before investors realize they aren't really doing too much work to make them money, but there are some PE firms out there that really take the time to research, invest, and support businesses that would have had a tough time finding footing. PE put to work to support female or black owned businesses for example, whether they mean to or not, are giving that community a chance to "start, finance, manage, and sell whatever their hustle" (from your words). Women and people of color have been dismissed historically in a capitalist society. So, in that respect, PE is doing something positive to lessen the gap of inequality for those communities. I am definitely not pitching that PE firms are "good people," but whether the intention is there they are "helping" the divide many anti-capitalists find frustrating about the structure.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you Michael for sharing your insights from Veblen. Just like Vultures have a role in nature to keep the circle of life going and evolving, like wise, I think PE also has a role in capitalism. Just like in nature, the bad actors will always be there and over time, the system will self-correct. However, this could take time, maybe decades just as the case is with evolution.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.