Is the power of money so that you can buy yourself power?
I love Marx's dissection of the power of money through this passage from Faust. Marx describes the idea of using money to fill in the gaps of your attributes that lend themselves to positive perception and, ultimately, power. He seems to value money as the ultimate winner when it comes to creating reputation. However, he describes the pitfalls of using it to buy the falsehoods that would push someone forward in life: "Money...save me the trouble of being dishonest: I am therefore presumed honest" (Marx, pp. 121). It is an interesting look at the power of money when it comes to influence and persuasion.
When we look at the great leaders in modern day, money has lost some of it's power. Characters like Bezos for instance are not able to save themselves from scrutiny because of the amount of wealth accumulated. In fact, one might argue that the extreme wealth he possesses makes him less trustworthy as a leader. The attributes he might possess without the stacks of money under him have become dimished because we resent the amount he was able to accumulate. However, his brilliance lives on because he managed to build a great company, and really buy more brilliance by hiring (and paying) employees that keep that stamp approval visible in that regard.
To return to the Goethe quote, as a leader, does paying great employees make you also a great leader? Do you "get to" own or claim for yourself the positive attributes of a company because you are the leader? If you are "ugly" or "dishonest" or "lame" (as Marx puts it) can you buy something that instead makes you an attractive, honest, and powerful leader?
Yes, Katie! As a capitalist, I'm ashamed to admit that the Karl Marx resonated with me too. His point that struck me the most was the "distorting power" of money. Look no further than the upcoming Barbarians at the Gate reading to find a CEO that buys loyalty through corporate pay and perks and threat of termination. When you see how people behave without explicit carrots and sticks, you can judge what Marx called their "individuality." A true test of leadership.
ReplyDeleteHi Katie, your title caught my eye since this portion of Marx's reading made me cringe, in thinking about how owning something can sometimes make another's attribute your own. I can't quite put my finger on why I feel this way. Maybe in a professional setting, it's because a leader should not accept their workers qualities as their own work, or maybe it's also from being burned too many times in the workplace when others do not give credit where credit is due. Regardless I also found Marx's reading interesting and money has a devious way of creating perceptions of others. Thanks for the interesting read!
ReplyDeleteThank you for your post, Katie.
ReplyDeleteTo answer your last question, our society decided that almost everything has a price. The only possibility that someone could buy anything (or anyone) they wanted makes them powerful de facto, and they get more and more power as our «own price» gets cheaper.
Someone can probably understand the artifacts that people value and buy them in an attempt to please them. But esteem and respect are probably the most expensive feelings to buy, depending on what someone's price is. Money is a good way to obtain something from people, but it also creates a distance and a limit to what people may to for you, in comparison of a leader who could mobilize people with his only passion and set of skills. It may be harder to gain such admiration from people if you can't reduce that distance between you and them, so I guess it's better to be genuine and build your leadership on priceless qualities, if that ever exists.