Monday, July 19, 2021

Is a micromanager a leader or a boss?


Veblen, in his text "Absentee Ownership," within the chapter "The Captain of Industry," explains how there was a character called "The captain of Industry" that "set out with being a pioneer in industrial enterprise, a designer, builder and manager of industrial equipment and a foreman of the work in hand. At the same time, he was a businessman and took care of the financial end of the enterprise, buying and selling, hiring and firing, investment and promotion" (Veblen, T., 1923). In other words, he was in charge of every decision made, both technical and business. However, Veblen mentions that in the 19th century, the industrial arts began to develop and advance so that the captain of the industry falls short and cannot cope with the same role in this new business environment. Veblen explains how he is forced by the nature of the new business to focus on the business side and leave technical decisions to other more technical leaders.

When reading this first part of the chapter, I immediately thought of micromanagers. Veblen exposed in the 19th century the unsustainability of this jack of all trades, as Professor Rollert called it. But, unfortunately, in the middle of the 21st century, this leadership style still exists.


The micromanager boss is the one who is always aware of his employees and how they work. He does not hesitate to make observations at every step of the worker and, although he usually does so with good intentions, it can be nerve-racking. This profile usually occurs in people who are too dominant or who have difficulties delegating. Consequently, they like everything to be done as they see fit and do not trust their subordinates' methods. Not to mention how inefficient this profile is for your micromanager productivity. After all, if the micromanager spends his time reviewing every detail of his office, he does not have time to do his work.


Falling into micromanagement is very easy if you don't have a clear team vision. Doing an introspection, I myself am a micromanager many times. However, I agree with what Veblen suggests about the complexity of business and the need to separate labor. I believe that high-performance teams are those that have different profiles that complement each other and contribute, with leadership that provides vision and direction without getting involved in every detail of the business. With this, I do not mean that a leader should not know the industry. If he does not know it in depth, he cannot set the correct vision or guide his team along the way, but he should not be aware of absolutely every detail of other people's work and want it to be done precisely the way he wants it.

1 comment:

  1. Thanks for sharing perspective from Veblen and your experience with Micromanaging. From my experience, I've seen this more with new Managers who have a hard time letting go and trusting their team. Having a trusting relationship is key to being able to delegate confidently. I agree completely that a micro manager is unlikely to be leading a high performance team.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.