Wednesday, July 14, 2021

Hells Angels Meets the Rotary Club

In Barbarians at the Gate, John Helyar details the cultural collision of the sleepy kind-tempered Nabisco executives and the outsized personalities that defined Standard Brands. The unique personality traits and communication means of Johnson and his Merry Men are significant features throughout the book and they are most spectacular against a backdrop of conservative and financial characters.

Through the reading, I couldn’t help but think of another colorful personality in the news, NHL Lightning player Nikita Kucherov. Here’s Kucherov in a recent Stanley Cup post-game Interview:

While the two settings are far removed, there are a few areas of important overlap. Both professional hockey and business are challenging competitive endeavors. While money pervades both hockey as well as the corporate world (Kucherov earns a yearly compensation package on the same magnitude of the current CEO of Nabisco), the coin of the realm in both cases seems likely to be related to performance. It would be challenging to imagine Johnson commanding the same level of respect by simply being wealthy but not being perceived as able to produce results. Similarly, Kucherov is valued for his perceived ability to help his team score points. Both command some respect for this future-looking expectation of performance. However, in Johnson’s case the reality appears complicated by political and social machinations that complicates an analysis on the value he provides.

In both cases, colorful personalities are tolerated. A shirtless swearing Kucherov can smile and throw back a bud light in a press conference as effortlessly as Johnson can mix in a line of creative profanity in an interview. But to what degree are they elemental parts of character that couldn’t possibly be removed? To what degree does this hallmark behavior reinforce an image of confidence that is beneficial to each?


Note that the title is from a beautiful comment in the book "It was, one wag noted, as if Hell's Angels had merged with the Rotary Club."

3 comments:

  1. Since I don't follow the NHL I was not familiar with Kucherov at all, so thank you for the introduction and video, and what a personality indeed. The good, bad and ugly aspects of these colorful personalities do indeed become part of their reputation and make them who they are.

    The late Herb Kelleher, the founder CEO of Southwest was another such larger than life personality that comes to mind. While he was much loved and respected, I've heard that female employees used to be wary of crossing his path lest they get smooched! In his days this behavior was spoken of endearingly. I'm not sure how it would be perceived this this day and age.

    The level of tolerance of these personalities would depend on how in tune they are with their followers and their collective culture.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh wow, this one reached me to the next level.
    As a proud Quebecer and Habs supporter, I was on the side of people who did not tolerate Kucherov's behavior, especially when he took a great pleasure to insult Montreal's fan club. Believe me, this guy should not set foot in Montreal for a very long time, because he made himself a national enemy in here after what he said. I will spare you all the profanities I’ve heard about him in the last week.

    According to my relatives, his behaviour was more a sign of arrogance and condescension rather than simple confidence. He was totally considered a bad winner, and the aspect of money made it even worse considering that canadian hockey players don’t have access to salary conditions as good as he has. So not only in my eyes it was deloyal competition, but he also tried to make himself appear better in diminishing his opponents’ efforts. In short, nothing professional or inspirational to see here.

    But I also recognize my biais in here, since our perception of a good leader is always subjective. The concrete accomplishment remains, but how they are perceived depends on the relationship we maintain. What we gain from the relationship, our proximity with the leader, our past experiences in similar contexts and the potential effect he can have on us are all factors that can monitor our reactions to his behavior.

    Since I am a supporter of Montreal Canadiens, obviously my perception of Kucherov’s behaviour is very negative. But a Lightning’s supporter may have a very different opinion since they won the cup by simply consider him a «colorful person». And the same dynamic probably occurred in Johnson’s career. Those who gained privileges may have seen him in a better eye than those who did not get anything from his eccentricities but still had to endure them.

    To answer your question, I think his exhuberance and his arrogance are probably traits he already show outside of cameras that we could not expect to change. But I am not even sure he could be considered authentic in the video you sent. When people have attention, not only the scrutiny of the public makes every trait seem bigger, but it also seems that some people exaggerate their own behaviour and become a caricature of themselves to give people what they want (a good show). That is what I see in your video. We can’t change Kucherov, but he can learn to control himself (and still be authentic, but less of a trash) (oops sorry)!

    ReplyDelete
  3. As Anto said, I don't follow the NHL, however, sports is certainly an area where out-sized personalities and charismatic players have been the focus of a lot of media attention. I would argue the more polarizing the behavior the less the attention has been about leadership, and more about celebrity. NBA players like Dennis Rodman come to mind. He was never viewed as a leader for his antics. His trade to the Chicago Bulls bumped his extreme style up against the steady personality of Michael Jordan, and although Rodman was able to help deliver some wins, he also took some risks, like staging a wrestling match against Hulk Hogan in the middle of the payoffs instead of showing up to practice. Teamwork seemed to take a backseat to publicity.

    Johnson however seemed to use his charisma and company-building escapades to leverage the support of his team--at least to the extent it would buy enough loyalty to get him what he wanted. He wielded his 'coins of the realm' with a natural expertise.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.