As the owner of a small company centered around machine learning and software development, I find myself often reaching for the pair questions of “can x be automated?” and “should x be automated”?
The answer to the former is usually straightforward, as we can automate almost everything over some timescale. The same forces that initially revolutionized the efficiency of textile manufacturing are now heavily influencing manufacturing, marketing, logistics, transportation, health care, legal services, food preparation, and even the creation of art itself, to name a few.
As a related note, the pixel display behind my desk, visible in most of our classes, is cycling through a piece of art created by a generative adversarial neural network that is depicting a dream-like abstract representation of a recent half-marathon, as captured through 10,000 photos from a GoPro strapped to my chest.
However, the answer to whether we should automate something is usually more complicated and interesting. For example, should we automate the sentencing of convicted criminals, or should we treat this as a sacred area reserved for human judgment?
Similarly, at the split second of a severe automobile accident, should we trust automation to choose on our behalf about what action to take, knowing that the activity may intentionally trade lives in the process?
Leadership is not immune to the advance of technology, the march of automation, and the related ethical questions that come along for the ride. We’re already starting to see tendrils cross lines as major organizations rely on sophisticated algorithms and neural networks for hiring and now even firing.
Just as a self-driving car is essentially a bucket of convenience features that pass a critical line of usefulness, so too will be the future of leadership automation. Software already helps us hire, fire, retain, motivate, and otherwise influence our workers. Each of those features is under rapid advancement by a fleet of competing companies. Leadership activities are valuable and expensive; automating them is highly profitable and desirable from at least a naive vantage. The future is evident within the relevant technology and forces; without intervention, a cohesive product that replaces centralized human leadership will become a reality.
Should we support this future or rally against it?
Scary and thought provoking at the same time. I think it's inevitable that more and more of Management will get automated. We see this happening in many fields and one that come to mind is in how call centers are managed. Voice to Text and Natural Language processing is now used to detect intra call sentiment changes and automatic call escalation without the need for human managers. Pay incentives and bonuses for call center staff are now determined by AI and machines.
ReplyDeleteBut for true Leadership, where new ideas and a vision is created and teams are motivated to follow, I think humans will continue to have the upper hand for sometime to come.
Thank you for clarifying what we see in you background every class, I was almost convinced it was an artificial moving wallpaper!!
ReplyDeleteYour question scares me to the core. On the other side, would you follow an automated device to lead you?
We are at a point where even creativity is not distinguishing anymore humans and robots, since they are able to generate by themselves algorithms of decisions and invent by themselves so many hypothesis. But still, the warmth, the relatable relation, the confidence and the adaptation are still human exclusive, and I hope it will be for at least a few years more.
Technology should be at the service of humans, and not the opposite. Only in our own history, we saw how standardized and inflexible leadership led people to revolutions, and it would not be different if we make it automated. Our empathy as humans working with humans is our richness, and I can't believe how stopping to believe in ourselves as gregarious beings would be of any help.