Monday, July 26, 2021

Final Question: Do we ask our leaders to lie to us?

In the season 6 episode 'In God We Trust' of the U.S. television series The West Wing, Presidential nominee Arnold Vinick (played by Alan Alda) is met with a dilemma. After securing his party's nomination Vinick's conceding opponent puts him in an awkward position by inviting him to attend church with him. Vinick on a personal level has not been religious in many years. The press begin to hound him about his religious beliefs and to see if he will accept the invitation. This begins to annoy Vinick, as he realizes the trap he could find himself in--either people will perceive him to be religious, or they will see through him and realize he is just trying to score political points. 

It is not so much the context of this episode that interests me, but the reasoning he uses to resolve the dilemma. In a short but powerful answer to a reporter's question about whether he will be attending church he replies, "I fully respect [my opponent's] position....I mean, I appreciate his invitation...and a...look, I respect [him] and I respect his church too much to use it for my own political purposes, and that's exactly what I would be doing if I went down there this Sunday. The truth is it would just be an act of political phoniness. I may be wrong, but I suspect our churches already have enough political phonies in them. I don't see how we can have a separation of church and state in this government if you have to pass a religious test to get in this government. And I want to warn everyone in the press and all the voters out there. If you demand expressions of religious faith from politicians you are just begging to be lied to. They will all lie to you, a lot of them will, and it will be the easiest lie they've ever had to tell to get your votes."

In a day of hyper-activism on so many issues I often return to this clip. Pick a hot topic and ask yourself, do we really want a genuine answer to our questions, or do we want someone who will be molded and shaped into a figurehead that will do what we want them to do? This applies in the workplace, the classroom, and our homes. In my opinion 'cancel culture' mindset has made more liars than it has made more authentic leaders. We sometimes mistake someone for being "empathetic" because they know what their answer should be and they know how to convincingly deliver the message, but are they just appeasing the masses?

So, my question--Do we ask our leaders to lie to us? How can we demand expression of certain values and beliefs with pitchforks raised and not expect those who value power to lie to us? I guess one could argue that if "the greater good" is achieved then it doesn't really matter if they lie--just that we get the answer we want. To what end will these performative expressions produce authentic and empathetic leadership?


2 comments:

  1. Thanks Curtis for the very thought provoking post and clip. As bad as it sounds, I think you are right and this is only getting worse given the scale and speed as which reputations can be made or broken in this day and age. For leaders at the national level, it takes a team to "Calculate" and communicate their Authenticity, using a term from Stephenie Rosenbloom's New York Times article "Authentic? Get Real". Authenticity "calculated" to mold the version of yourself that your followers seek may end up being a lie.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Curtis. Many thanks for your post. I think you know the answer to your own question -- of course we do! We don't trust them, so we'd at least like to know that they meet our core criteria to minimize the case they'll screw us. You know what? I don't think they trust us either, that we would not discount them if they failed to check certain boxes. This only changes through honest dialogue, when we trust that they're leveling with us, and they trust that we're not mindless bots.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.