After reading Daniel Boorstin’s “The Image” this weekend, I was struck by his distinction between a Big Man and a Big Name.
In class today, Presentation Group #1 introduced us to Ernest Shackleton, who left behind an amazing legacy of grit and inspirational loyalty. Given that the accounts of that time were often one-sided puff pieces rather than critical biographies, how much of the legend is based on fact and how much is simply based on what we would like to believe about him?
Boorstin also describes a trend line from someone being known for accomplishment to simply for their “well-knownness,” or fame. Do you remember Sully Sullenberger who heroically landed a jet packed with passengers on the Hudson River? Thanks to the media, he then became a celebrity. Then he reinforced his fame by writing a book, serving as the subject for a movie starring Tom Hanks and for, more recently, a political commentator during the 2020 USA presidential election.
Often, the biggest “men” (who are often not men, of course) don’t have — and don’t want — big names. Two examples. My friend, Marcie, has for years taken time from her busy career to gather donated bicycles for a women’s shelter. She doesn’t post it on Facebook and she doesn’t seek publicity for the life-changing work she does. Another example: anonymous donors. What could be more selfless than donating money to worthy causes for no publicity in return? Compare that to some of the stories in today’s class from Rebecca Fassio about nine-figure donors and demands for strings attached.
In this time where social media can manufacture a Big Name way faster than Boorstin imagined, there’s an important message. We still live among heroes. Unfortunately, we look for them in the wrong places and they don’t wear superhero uniforms. You won’t find them on social, broadcast or print media. They walk among us. All you have to do is stop and look at, for example, the volunteers at your local community center, the educators who teach your kids, the law enforcement and military personnel who keep you safe, and the doctors and nurses who keep you alive.

Thank you for your post, Michael. I was also fascinated by Boorstin's text, and even more about this notion of anonymous heroes, especially since the pandemic when the society recognized the crucial contribution of essential workers.
ReplyDeleteI work with nurses and doctors every day, and I will be a doctor myself soon enough. So I know how exceptional is everybody's contribution, but also how frequent it is in the field. That notion of hero is of course very flattering to receive, but also a little intriguing because there is nothing «unique» about what we do.
I can't help but question myself about the notion of hero itself, and the place of the public eye to describe it. Can someone really be a hero if no one knows what they do? If someone is part of the obscurity of the crowd, can he really be considered in the light and approbation of the public? And believe me, I admire so much the work and contribution of these people, and they are no less than amazing humans. But from the way I conceive it, what makes the difference between a honest worker or an exceptional being and a hero is the admiration of the public. The hero becomes one after experiencing the process of building a narrative of his noble accomplishments and submit it to the public that naturally becomes amazed and inspired. There is something honorable when someone shows humility even in the greatness, but I am not sure you can be considered a hero if you don't exist in other people's eyes. But hey, I am very open to discussion about it here!
What do you think?
I love your point, Isabelle. Does a heroic act only become one after it is publicized? It seems to me that we then cross over into pursuing fame. Perhaps it has to do with intent; as a leader, are we publicly claiming it so that people will follow us to accomplish a noble mission. Or are we doing it simply to remain famous?
DeleteHi Michael, I love this post and it's true many people look in the wrong places to find role models or real life superheroes. It's a shame that people flaunt their philanthropic efforts simply to be recognized or expecting something in return. I feel there is a distinguishable line between posting on social media to promote a cause or promote yourself through aiding a cause. I think viewers sometimes have a hard time deciphering between the two. I agree people should start looking into their local communities for volunteer opportunities and promoting real local heroes.
ReplyDeleteIndeed, Cassie. I think we must do a better job sourcing facts so we can decide who is a hero and who is 'peacocking!'
Delete