We all know someone who went fishing ten years ago and still brags about that 3 feet-long salmon they caught. Fun fact, most of the time, no one have proofs of such a trophy and this amazing story remains in the annals of personal pride forever. Everytime, I find it funny and I try to look impressed, even if it’s more to please than to sincerely have admiration for them. Sadly, I can make a parallel with some «leaders» I know.
My point here is about the importance of reputation and collective memory in the project of leadership. Ulysse says how a man is only as good as his reputation, which is valid. Having a bad reputation can literally destroy all your chances of success and leadership. Even though, a good reputation is still not enough because it’s not only what you’ve done that matters, it’s also what you do in the present time. Like Ulysses claims, «To have done is to hang/Quite out of fashion, like a rusty mail/in monumental mock’ry».
To refer to our pedigree to justify where we’re at today and why we should be considered as a leader is the best proof that someone’s claim to leadership is not that solid. Past accomplishments may contribute to your reputation, your credibility and the respect that people show you. But boastfulness without concrete action is a sign that someone’s evolution starts to slow down and is a sign of complacency. The battle you won thirty years ago, when nothing significant came after, sadly has the same anecdotic value as the big salmon your uncle caught in his last fishing trip in 1986. Not only it shows the importance of humility for a leader, but also the need to constantly work to remain relevant to others, which is one of the keys to maintain leadership.
There is nothing static about a leader. A leader is someone who moves, who is proactive, who can be fluid and adaptable in different situations and who brings people with him to achieve goals. When a leader stops, he becomes a statue, just like those we see in public parks. People may stop by, and even be interested and inspired, but they will go on and continue their own path.
And let me clarify one aspect. I don’t believe that leaders must start revolutions or win honours at all times to have the right to be considered leaders. At a certain point, all of these experiences builds a strong persona that people value and inspire themselves from when in need. But a good leader is not someone who stops someday and rests on his laurels. It is someone who can learn from these experiences and enrich his decisions in order to make the best out of it for everybody. After all, just like Ulysses says, «perseverance keeps honour bright», so send these bragging fishermen back to the pond!
Well said. It seems clear that humility is an essential leadership ingredient and (recently in our readings) Defoe and Franklin have both emphasized the importance of being humble. Similarly, a 2018 HBR article referred to the presence of "evidence that humble leaders do, in fact, outperform arrogant leaders"(https://hbr.org/2018/10/if-humility-is-so-important-why-are-leaders-so-arrogant). This aligns with my own personal experiences, I strongly prefer to work with people with modesty and humility and - assuming others share my preference - try to act the same way.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I wonder if it's possible to be a good leader without embracing humility. Are there ever times when it might be better to strategically embrace ego?
Isabelle, your thought about leader's not being static is very insightful. It's one aspect of leadership we haven't really discussed yet. Aside from some of the characteristics we are studying in these readings the ability to move forward with momentum and decisive action is something many who lack leadership skills struggle with. Either they are too focused on getting things just right that they don't ever take the next step forward, or they can be so crippled by anxiety and fear of making wrong decisions that they are not effective in their roles.
ReplyDeleteOne of my observations along these lines is that the best leaders I have worked with know how to consume and distill information, gather feedback and then pinpoint their next actions--the next actions don't even have to be the correct actions--just something that pushes the work forward. They know they may have to correct course, or tweak their approach. They are not afraid of potential mistakes and peril, but more focused on their goals.