My name is Katie Sugrue and I currently
reside in Boston, MA. I can say
currently because my husband and I trying to decide what the next move will be
for our growing family. I grew up in Northern California and he grew up in
Dublin, Ireland, so the debate is on as to who’s family we should be near.
I have worked most of my
professional career in the Financial sector, in all sorts of capacities and
working my way up from sales assistant, to broker, and now in Legal and
Compliance. I have had the great fortune of working for (mostly) fantastic
leaders. My current company’s CEO is someone many people admire and who I
personally have admired for a long time for his business saavy and unbelievable
intelligence. My admiration has extended beyond professional as I have gotten
to know him personally and heard him speak passionately about his personal and
political beliefs.
Because of my good luck with
personal leadership, I have high expectations for what I think makes a great leader…
and can pick out a bad manager from any lineup.
Going into this course, I have
thought about the difference between those two things: leaders and managers. They
are two different roles and don’t necessarily overlap. John Paul’s discussion
about Charismatic and Technocratic forms of leaders highlights what the
difference can be at a very basic level. We would expect a manager to have the
technocratic skills – strategic planning, problem solving, follow through,
etc.. However, often there is a lack of the EQ that we would want in a great
leader. I believe it’s an important distinction and one that is often
overlooked. A solution would be more leadership training for management (as
opposed to the ad nauseam management training organizations automatically fall
back on).
Great observations on Leaders vs. Managers Katie.
ReplyDeleteI think, we need good Managers and Leaders in today's organizations. Leaders tell us where we're going and Managers tell us how we get there. A Leader is Future driven and a Manager is Process driven. Leaders wield Influence, Managers wield Authority.
Totally agree we need both. I think we need to understand the distinction between the two. A great leader does not necessarily make a great manager, and a great manager does not necessarily make a great leader. I think there can be overlap, but it is probably more rare than we might choose to believe in the corporate world.
DeleteHello Katie, Thank you for sharing your amazing background! I'm looking forward to learn with (and from) you in the next weeks!
ReplyDeleteYour comparison of manager vs leader made me think about my own work context at the hospital. Every day, we feel tension about the ownership of leadership in the healthcare system. On one hand, you have the people from the medical staff that gain respect and management responsibilities because of their expertise and the trust they are given by their medical colleagues. On the other side, you have the pure managers that have no medical background but are taking administrative decisions to make the system work. Both sides are leaders in their own fields and must work together, but also advocate for the needs of their respective jobs, which are more than often contradictory. And this «advocating fonction» is probably the only little thing that allow them to be considered leaders instead of managers…
As far as I know, these two categories are both pure technocratic leaders, at least in my hospital. They own their responsibilities because they have the skills to fulfill them. I can't help but wonder how easier it would be if both had a little more of that charismatic leadership that would allow them to communicate and collaborate more efficiently. I agree so much on your suggestion for leadership training for management. The «charisma» and the leading skills are probably the missing ingredient that could bring closer those two fields of expertise that must work together even if their respective goals are, at first sight, different.
Have a nice day!
Isabelle, You certianly will bring an interesting perspective to this course. The health world and institutions definitely operate in their own way and develop leaders by different means than what corporations might deem "traditional." Expertise over tenure might be more valued in medicine than other organizations. I can't wait to hear more about your view within your field!
Delete