Why does our culture glorify gossip and slanderous banter of others? So many popular television shows and gossip columns are endorsed and recognized as one of the top entertainment choice for viewers. For example, “Pretty Little Liars” was one of the highest viewed TV shows by teenagers and young adults from 2010 – 2017. This show attracts viewers in with its murder mystery in trying to solve who killed Allison, who is A, and what is fabricated versus reality? The series was able to create 160 episodes worth of mystery and gossip for its loyal fan base that kept coming back
Another example of this addiction to deceit and curiosity within fallacies, is the book and television series, Gossip Girl. This show ran on glorified gossip, the sweetness of revenge, and mountains of secrets that could rip away the dignity of the even the most trusted and highly regarded individuals.
Why do we as people find untruthful and discriminating info so captivating? Do we really ever stop to think about how this fictitious gossip effects those around us, or how it can change the way someone perceives another person?
DeFoe points out how disastrous a small rumor can be, from evolving over time as small rumor to a life altering incident. In the words of DeFoe “So small a rumour will overset a tradesman, if he is not very careful of himself; and if a word in jest from himself, which though indeed no man that had considered things, or thought before he spoke, would have said (and, on the other hand, no man who had been wise and thinking would have taken as it was taken)--I say, if a word taken from the tradesman's own mouth could be so fatal, and run such a dangerous length, what may not words spoken slyly, and secretly, and maliciously, be made to do?”
Why do we individually want others to see us as a respectable, loyal, honorable, and trustworthy person, and then slander or misspeak of others who wish to be viewed in the same light? Do people realize the power within their words and their perceptions of others? This can be related to all aspects of ordinary life, but one major area where we want to be seen in high regard is in the workplace. We can control our own actions and prove our worth in the office with hard work ethic and charisma, but we are unable to control how our colleagues perceive us.
At least within hospitality, word of mouth spread like wildfire and rarely was the topic of conversation ever questioned in its accuracy. This led to many predetermined notions of others where employees did not take initiative to get to know people before creating their own opinions of others. This led to many toxic work environments and a high turnover rate at all of the event venues I worked for. Luckily at my new employer the managers do not partake in office gossip and we are all encouraged to meet with new colleagues individually to create an authentic connection. We are also encouraged to ask ourselves and others for feedback on how we work together to learn our own leadership and work styles. Teamwork, feedback, trainings, and practice is how my current department and employer form our professional and personal skills. I am eternally grateful to now see how continued education and learning from others enhances my understanding of how to grow and continue to become a better leader and person overall. I will continue to ask the question of "Why?" and follow the Golden Rule.
Hello Cassie,
ReplyDeleteI must mention I also thought right away about Gossip Girl when I read the Defoe text.
In Defoe and Smith's readings of this week, they all seem to say that people want what they can't have. We admire the nobles because we won't ever be like them. In a certain way, we are thrilled by these behaviour because they reflect on qualities we deeply esteem in our society.
There is something very fascinating about seeing those behaviour that are «prohibited» in order to preserve the rules of society. But in fact, being rude to a waiter in a restaurant may be perceived as confidence or a high level of self-esteem, which are qualities that not everyone can pretend to hold.
Whatever if people don't do it because they fear the consequences of because they truly believe it ain't right, we are always curious about what we don't know or what we will never be!
Hi Cassie, Enjoyed reading your blog. I think Gossiping is a way humans bond socially and it can also be a good thing if it's positive. I'd think, the spread of good gossip true or otherwise can help with one's reputation. Now, my imagination is going wild and I'm wondering if some successful leaders have their own circle of influencers that spread good gossip about them that help them build and sustain their reputation and hence maintain their position of leadership?
ReplyDeleteIt sounds like you have a highly functional current work environment, thanks for sharing your past and current experiences.
ReplyDeleteA distinction between professional and non-professional settings is interesting. Defoe - like Smith, also from the 1700s - seems to emphasize the importance of reputation and social credit in a professional setting and the damaging effects of slander. But what about a non-professional setting? Can you be a good business owner or leader and engage in light-hearted gossip on the side?
Good for you, Cassie, that you found a place that is a healthier work environment and more consistent with your values.
ReplyDeleteWhy do we as humans find gossip so delicious? I suppose it's like sugar and empty carbs...it feels good while consuming it even if we know it's unhealthy. And, at least in the States, we seem to delight in building up public figures into these mannequins of perfection and then tearing them down.
I appreciated Defoe's sentiment of making people aware that an offhand comment in a coffee shop could lead to a run on a bank or a ruined author. I agree with you that The Golden Rule is the right guiding principle. What happens, though, when others don't adopt the same approach? What would Defoe suggest we do if we were leading a business that was the target of fake Trip Advisor reviews, doctored videos posted on line or slanderous lawsuits?
Hello Cassie, interesting reflection on how society values and enjoys gossip, this causes a never ending gossip loop. Personally, I have seen and enjoyed both of the aforementioned series and have never questioned the morbid plot.
ReplyDelete