Please keep this between us: my wife and daughter love watching "The Bachelor" reality TV show. One of the more common refrains from certain contestants involves whether other contestants are there for the right reasons. Are they on the show with honest motives, or is it really just a publicity play?
This week's reading included Adam Smith's "The Theory of Moral Sentiments." Published in 1759, Smith's theory remains relevant today.
For roughly 25 years, I worked for one of the world's largest asset managers, which managed money for large institutional investors that included corporations, universities and insurance companies. In 2001, my manager asked me to take on a leadership role that I was not seeking. In accepting, I quickly found myself in a snake pit.
My work environment was fast-paced, highly competitive and intellectually stimulating. We recruited people who were smart, ambitious and aggressive. Higher rank in the company offered more power and more money. What could possibly go wrong?!
To my eyes, some managers were -- like me -- there for the right reasons. We were genuinely trying to contribute to building out the business. We collaborated when needed, because it benefited the firm and our own business units. Adam Smith might have said they we were seeking praiseworthiness rather than pure praise.
Then, there were some other managers. Given what was at stake, you can probably imagine the sorts of people that might seek positions of power in the most capitalistic of businesses in the country that is the world's prototype for capitalism. They showed no interest in working together. They saw interactions with other business units and leaders as competitions to be won, zero-sum transactions.
I retired from that business in 2010 so I have gained perspective. I now look back on that second group of managers as organizational politicians. Their core competency was political skill. The means through which they often gained the role and managed their business was what Smith called "flattery and falsehood." Their driving motive was personal gain. What they sought was the envy and attention of others -- directly through their stature at work, and indirectly through the expensive neighborhoods they lived in and the pricey cars they drove.
There was another valuable insight offered by Smith that aspiring managers should take note of. When gaining rank as a leader, it's tempting to draw confidence through comparisons to subordinates or those less senior in the organization. Smith provided a more meaningful yardstick, the "archetype of perfection." When I think of the artists and athletes I admire the most -- Roger Federer, Scottie Pippen, Meryl Streep, Miles Davis -- it's those who are driven to be not the best relative to others, but their best. Where others might be content with the fame, money, trophies and awards, these performers pursue(d) their own conception of perfect.
Why did this resonate with me? Perhaps it's the same reason that you and I are HES classmates. Is it for the praise of others, or is it to bring us closer to our own archetypes of perfect? Which begs the question: are we here for the right reasons?

I like your term "organizational politicians." There is certainly an element of this in many companies. From my own experience the larger the company the more organizational politicians there are. Especially in middle-management as the competition increases for executive and higher leadership positions. I would also argue that some organizations create this type of persona. As you laid out in your post a high reward culture without incentives for cooperation become more cutthroat and aggressive.
ReplyDeleteOne of my clients seemed to recognize this type of environment was becoming counter productive to their real goals. Keeping that hockey stick going up and to the right was more challenging when people stopped competing and let the less-skilled but better politicians "win" (i.e. those who wanted a cooperative work environment quit). This left the politicians with fewer competitors, revealed their weaknesses, or put more pressure on them to perform at higher and higher levels. In this perfect storm, my client came to understand that a new approach was necessary to encourage the right kinds of behavior. This required them to re-tool their comp plans and re-think what kind of individuals they really wanted to lead. Leadership had to became more about building a sustainable culture and less about the numbers. The numbers follow when the culture breeds fewer politicians.
Michael,
ReplyDeleteI've never heard "organizational politicians" before, but I love it! The term doesn't even require an explanation.
Both Adam Grant and Malcolm Gladwell have podcasts that overlap, and a recent discussion between them led to Lebron James and his greatness. They basically said that it's not his maximum performance that makes him great, it's his typical performance. This translates to the workforce when we discuss employees and their typical performance versus optimal performance. A high ceiling is great, but Grant and Gladwell assert that it's better to be consistently good than intermittently excellent. Thank you for your thoughts!
"Their core competency was political skill." So smart and astute. I see managers who have perfected their business politics game and have met success. However, the substance behind this skill is nil. I for one am not all that great at the office politics. I have a grasp on it, I can identify it, and I can employ it when I need to be, but at what cost? I often find myself feeling "icky" after strategically maneuvering around the red tape. While it is necessary in any modern corporate setting, I resent the politics of promotion of and leadership. I have found the "CYA" (cover your ass) existence of managers infuriating as a direct report and the subsequent burnout of working under leadership like that is real. Your highlight of admiring those that strive towards the best version of self rather than the best version among others is an important lesson for us all to take into every facet of life. I want to be the best partner to my husband, the best mother to my children, and the best friend/sister/neighbor to others. We should all shun away from these false pretenses of what a perfect wife, mother, daughter, friend is purported to be the politics of it all!
ReplyDeleteHi Michael, your wife and daughter have great taste! I have noticed over the years the increased amount of publicity for the contestants on the Bachelor/Bachelorette creates a great income for the influencers. I appreciate your insight and reflection on how you and others in your former workplace collaborated and completed your work responsibilities. I am curious to see the difference in happiness or purpose levels between the individuals who worked for status and personal gain, versus the individuals who worked for the betterment of others and working together. How large is the gap in self-fulfillment and happiness? Only time will tell. Thanks again for sharing!
ReplyDeleteI relate deeply with your blog, Michael.
ReplyDeleteThe flashy cars and the ostentatious houses are very often considered normal (and even sometimes expected) when someone reaches the higher levels of an organization. But these people, by trying to correspond to what is expected from them, won't ever go further or be better than the model they fixed themselves to reach.
Even if there are special characteristics of leadership, there is no single best way to be a leader. In fact, the key to be the best is to invest ourself in a self-development journey and to seek for feedback. Modeling our behaviour on someone else's, like these «organizational politicians» you describe, is a statement on itself about their motivation and the maximum development they can reach as a person.
But in fact, just like this famous Buffet we talked about last week, it's in this idea of being coherent to what we are and to do the things because we want to, and not because we have to, that leads to success in a much greater scale.